Island Reviews (2219)

Reviews

A restaurant without a rating is almost like a beer garden without a guest. Menulist has collected all reviews for Island so you can get an impression based on the opinions of other guests. So far, there are 2219 opinions found on 2 pages. The average rating for Island is 4.1, which means guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help our visitors with your review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4.1 out of 5

Impressive | 2219 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Island from all websites.

themarketinvestor

07.08.2023 - 05:22

This used to be my favorite neighborhood place and over 30 years after moving away it's still a reliable standby. Great ambiance. Warm and intimate. The bistro...

eduardo-911

07.08.2023 - 05:22

We love Island. The menu and ambience uniquely reflects this neighborhood in the upper Manhattan. Service is top notch as well, you feel at home. Try the lobste...

nikola-137

07.08.2023 - 05:22

Delicious food. Tried the Island burger and the Maryland Crabcake sliders

juju-20

07.08.2023 - 05:22

This restaurant sits right on Madison Ave very close to Central Park. It is very cozy but super cute too. I arrived right Brunch and lunch time and even though...

nancy-100

07.08.2023 - 05:22

Went here for lunch with my coworker, I order the tuna tartar as a starter and it was sooo good, for entrée I had the lobster quesadillas and my oh my it sure l...

Last update : 07.08.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near New York

Oceans New York

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New York, 233 Park Ave S, 10003, New York, United States

Non-Smoking, Wheelchair Access, Cocktails, Terrace

##2 Seafood in New York

Details

#2 Seafood in New York Sushi Asiatic

4 Charles Prime Rib

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New York, 4 Charles St #3004, 10014, New York, US, United States

"One of those places that actually lives up to the hype. The food is delicious and decadent. The service is professional and attentive, but easygoing. IMHO this is the best burger in NYC and the French dip might even be better. Prime rib was good, but a bit expensive for what you get. Sides are all A+, best fries ever."

##10 Fast Food in New York

Details

#10 Fast Food in New York Seafood

Sushi Katsuei West Village

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New York, 357 Avenue Of The Americas, 10014, New York, United States

"Strongly recommended by my friend, we came here to celebrate my friend's birthday. Enjoyed very much the delicious, fresh and beautiful set of Omakase. We also had daikon and hijiki salad. The service was excellent and my friend was extremely happy. Aperfect dinner for a special occasion. Definitely recommended!"

#Sushi

Details

Sushi Japanese Fish Pub Asian

Mark's Off Madison

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New York, 41 Madison Ave, New York, United States Of America

"Loved it!!!"

#Italian

Details

Italian Coffee Pasta Fish Meat

Summer Salt

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New York, 30 E 23rd St, 10010, New York, US, United States

"Thought I found the best spot close to my job for lunch. I even told everyone at my job about this place (Madison and 39th St location). Long story short I received spoiled seafood twice within a 6 week span. The first time I got seared fish that was spoiled. I didn't complain then as I do not like to complain and I just hoped it was a one off incident. Fast forward to this evening, I got spoiled shrimp. I called the restaurant and a Hispanic guy answered then hung up on me when I tried to explain that the shrimps in my meal was spoiled. I called back several times and no answer. I really hate to give 2 stars but at this moment if it was any other store I would probably give 1 star"

##3 Mexican in New York

Details

#3 Mexican in New York Seafood Tacos

Los Tacos No.1

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New York, 136 Church St, 10007, New York, US, United States

"First time here and already planning the next trip back. These tacos were outstanding. I got both chicken pork the pork stole the show for me but the chicken was also good. Toppings are great too, and you can't beat the quality for the price!"

##1 Mexican in New York

Details

#1 Mexican in New York Vegetarian