Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Erick Arroyo likes about Made In New York Pizza:
On the pricier side of slices I've had here in New York, but it does not disappoint! EVER. I've been coming back every other day, feels like a dream come true. Would not miss out on recommending this place to anyone. View all feedback.
What Tschui doesn't like about Made In New York Pizza:
Of all the New York pizza I've had, this one impressed me the least. Too much cheese and half of the toppings were burnt. But it tasted okay. Probably wouldn't come back. View all feedback.
Slice pizza goooood, garlic knots delicious. Hungry after drinks ? This is the place ! Delicious
Nice place. Good number of tables. Clean dining area and toilets. Staff were friendly and patient with out-of-towners unfamiliar with NYC-style pizza. The pizza itself was really good; really nice sauce; wide selection. I had plain cheese, which was on the mark. If you’re visiting the Natural History Museum or hanging out in beautiful CPW, this is great place for lunch.
Average takeaway pizza. The most practical solution to satisfy your hunger while traveling around NY
Delicious pizza with a variety of options and fair prices. Definitely recommend!!
Great pizza. Got the vodka and Margherita. Casual and comfortable place to sit and eat.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
