Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Timothy's Of Newark:
Lived college sports bar on a Saturday night. Pub food that is not fancy, but well prepared. Many screens with sport, mix of students and locals. Large parking, so it is easy to visit. We eat there after the theater. Large fish tank in the center of the dining area. View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Timothy's Of Newark:
Never been to a Timothy before and was sadly disappointed. Firstly, was the waiting personnel dressed in hoodies and sports jerseys, which might be normal for this place? *Shrug* I mention this only because it was very hard to see who was an employee. Our waiter was beautiful and mostly attentive. The most disappointing was the food. The garlic friries were licky, but unfortunately had absolutely no salt. My steak wa... View all feedback.
Lived college sports bar on a Saturday night. Pub food that is not fancy, but well prepared. Many screens with sport, mix of students and locals. Large parking, so it is easy to visit. We eat there after the theater. Large fish tank in the center of the dining area.
I only ate at Timothy and it's an incredible experience. The waiter was on top and my server Jack was so real and on top... the food was incredible!!!! I ordered the ribeye with sweet potato bags and broccoli and the sweet potato bags were some of the best I ever had while the steak came out in time and boiled to a perfect medium rare temperature. I would totally love to dip the note in a powder sugar or caramel sauce, but they were themselves delicious!!
Never been to a Timothy before and was sadly disappointed. Firstly, was the waiting personnel dressed in hoodies and sports jerseys, which might be normal for this place? *Shrug* I mention this only because it was very hard to see who was an employee. Our waiter was beautiful and mostly attentive. The most disappointing was the food. The garlic friries were licky, but unfortunately had absolutely no salt. My steak was cooked well, but only had a sad piece of bacon when it was to be completely wrapped in it. My friend Steak was overdue and hard. (We both said medium rarely) Last came my meal with unseasoned mushy broccoli. Beautiful sports bar atmosphere and young friendly waiting staff, but unfortunately the food seemed to be met or miss.
Food tastes pretty good, but it became more and more inconsistent in recent months. The burgers are especially safe for the price. However, the pages leave much to wish. To distribute $5 dollars for onion rings, I would expect that share and quality over what I would expect from a fast food joint to a minimum. Quality has slowed down to some of its options lately (more recently onion rings)
Attended a baby shower on the second floor of restaurant. Fantastic buffet food, clean and soft, chewy chocolate chip cookies. Beautiful space for a special occasion with a sports bar on first floor.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
