Cosimo's Pizza - Newburgh

Here you can find the menu of Cosimo's Pizza in Newburgh. At the moment, there are 5 meals and drinks on the menu. You can inquire about changing offers via phone.

What User likes about Cosimo's Pizza:
eat here. eating is 10/10 good. and service is absolutely amazing. I'll tap every time, I'll eat there. no problems with waitress. If you've eaten almost the year there, they'll find out what I wanted is out there. I have no evidence of why this place has some bad reviews. this is only the best part of the small newburgh mall sad. read more.

When the weather conditions is pleasant you can also eat outside.

What User doesn't like about Cosimo's Pizza:
Dont like the baked ziti. It's nothing baked about it and the pasta taste like they made them this morning and had them sitting out all day. Slapped my food with the sauce together and threw it in the microwave to make it hot... so disappointed. This is my 1st time eating here and might be my last. Maybe next time I'll just get pizza. Stick to the basics. read more.

Delicious pizza is baked hot from the oven at Cosimo's Pizza in Newburgh using a traditional method.