New York Bagel Cafe Reviews (85)

Reviews

Menulist has collected all the reviews for New York Bagel Cafe from all important portals to give you a comprehensive impression. Currently, there are 85 reviews from 2 website(s) available to you. The average rating for New York Bagel Cafe is 3.6 which means that the vast majority of its guests was satisfied with its service. Help our visitors with your review for this restaurant!.

Overall Total Score

3.6 out of 5

Very good | 85 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for New York Bagel Cafe from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (3.6 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Newburgh.

garrison11

18.09.2023 - 10:12

So far the best bialy and egg bagel in the area! The place is always busy and you have to get there early to get a full selection. I don’t give 5 stars often bu...

langworth-felicity

18.09.2023 - 10:12

Best bacon egg and cheese on a bagel you can get around here. The bacon is always perfectly crispy and the everything bagel seasoning is top notch. The staff is...

owaters

18.09.2023 - 10:12

Best bagels around, been coming here for years now. Service has been phenomenal, especially post-quarantine. My egg sandwich is always spot on it’s been especia...

lsporer-1

18.09.2023 - 10:12

Bagels are great, people are nice, place is clean and beautiful. Shame on the people leaving 1-star reviews, this is not a 1-star business... wish I could respo...

Last update : 18.09.2023

godfrey-29

03.05.2022 - 01:54

Delicious bagels and best Taylor ham egg & cheese around. Always gets my order right.

Last update : 03.05.2022

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near Newburgh

Talavera

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: New Windsor (near Newburgh), 1008 Little Britain Rd, 12553, New Windsor, US, United States

Vegan Options, Accepts Credit Cards, Reservations, Wifi

##1 Vegetarian in New Wind...

Details

#1 Vegetarian in New Windsor

Toppings Frozen Yogurt

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: New Windsor (near Newburgh), 287 Windsor Hwy Ste 300, New Windsor, New York, USA, 12553, United States

"Amazing customer service. Nice place to visit."

##1 Vegetarian in New Wind...

Details

#1 Vegetarian in New Windsor Yogurt

Seafood Village

4.6

Online table booking

4.6

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, 47 N Plank Rd, Newburgh, United States

"The Food was 1 Star and I Paid $26 for a $12 Meal. Over Priced and the Food Sucks. I'm going back to Japanese Express and Get Delicious and a Big Take Out Box of Hibachi Steak and Chicken with Fried Rice for $12 Tax Included Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 2"

##9 Seafood in Newburgh

Details

#9 Seafood in Newburgh Sushi Asiatic

Vesuvio's

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, 300 Dupont Ave, Newburgh, United States

Takeout, Parking, TV, Wheelchair Accessible

##4 Vegetarian in Newburgh

Details

#4 Vegetarian in Newburgh Seafood

Mary Jane's Dairy

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, 5334 Route 9w, Newburgh I-12550-1323, United States

"Took 20 minutes to get one scoop of vanilla. Was the only one there and I ordered maple walnut."

##6 Cafés in Newburgh

Details

#6 Cafés in Newburgh

Super Kennedy Fried Chicken

4.4

City: Newburgh, 136 Lake St, 12550, Newburgh, US, United States

"Lamb n Chicken over basmati..bussin"

##4 Fast Food in Newburgh

Details

#4 Fast Food in Newburgh Chicken

Ihop

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, 44 NY-17K, 12550, Newburgh, US, United States

"Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##7 Fast Food in Newburgh

Details

#7 Fast Food in Newburgh

Captain Jake's

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, Front Street, Newburgh, United States Of America

"This was our Valentine's Day dinner. Everything went well, great company, excellent food and service. It’s not a huge menu; but there is enough variety to find something. For those who care there are 2 washrooms that are gender neutral. I don't know why any negative reviews; this is our second visit and we're very particular about our seafood. NO COMPLAINTS here. For a starter we had a clams oregenata; an actual clam in a delicious sauce. Perfectly cooked and executed. I tried the sole francaise with a potato croquet and broccoli. Both the sole and potato were amazing. Hot, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. I'm not a broccoli fan, so I can't comment on the vegetable. Although the size of the fillet was closer to the size of a flounder fillet. It was still toothsome morsel. I've caught and cleaned enough of both, but nevertheless it wasn't over cooked. She had the seared sea scallops. Not even a Michelin star celebrity chef would have a complaint with the way they were prepared. The portions are just enough and the flavors complimentary. The margarita wasn't boozy, too sweet, or unbalanced. It was a sipping drink that went down smoothly. She thoroughly enjoyed her Bloody Mary. It too, was just right. The espresso had actual schiuma! You need a machine for that. I just can't believe this restaurant isn't on coast; where really fresh seafood is always available and the patrons are used to exceptional seafood prepared and served to perfection. That's why the five star rating; if I could give an extra star I would."

##5 Pizza in Newburgh

Details

#5 Pizza in Newburgh Seafood Cafés

Papa John's Pizza

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, 60 N Plank Rd, Newburgh, NY 12550-2116, United States

"They do not wear gloves. They do not wear masks.I didn't see them wash their hands... Hmmm.1st time there....not going back."

##15 Pizza in Newburgh

Details

#15 Pizza in Newburgh American

Cosimo's

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Newburgh, 1217 Union Ave., Newburgh, United States Of America

"The penne vodka is some of the best I’ve ever had! We also did a make your own pizza, which was decent but nothing extraordinary. It’s our go to spot on our way back from the yankee games. Highly recommend Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30"

##9 Pizza in Newburgh

Details

#9 Pizza in Newburgh Italian