Buttermilk Baking Company - Newburyport

The average review of 4.5 shows that the restaurant is one of the top spots of all its visitors.

What Michele Gormley likes about Buttermilk Baking Company:
This bakery is a treasure! Everything I have bought has been a huge success. Their pies, cookies and honey biscuits are so delicious. At least twice a month we order a chicken pot pie for dinner. Truly the best in the area. What makes it such a special place though is the customer service. You can order ahead, place a special custom order and even ship a gift anywhere in the country. Thank you to Ashley and the team... View all feedback.

What Ryann Fritsch doesn't like about Buttermilk Baking Company:
It was awhile ago but my husband ordered a birthday cake from them for my birthday. It tasted terrible. The butter cream tasted spoiled (we had a cake priorit was delicious). We contacted them and the response we got was oh well . So we paid a lot for a crappy cake with crappy service. I refuse to go back and have told others to stay away. If that is how they are going to treat customers. View all feedback.