Anthony John's Pizzeria Reviews (336)

Reviews

So that you don't dive naively into a new culinary adventure, Menulist has compiled all the ratings for Anthony John's Pizzeria from various websites, so you can get a transparent picture. So far there are 336 ratings found on 5 pages. On average, Anthony John's Pizzeria was rated 4.4. This means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help our community find the best spots and submit a review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4.4 out of 5

Impressive | 336 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Anthony John's Pizzeria from all websites.

rocco-83

28.08.2023 - 07:06

Wanted to like this place since it is close to my new home, but after trying it with my family 3 times, we will not return. Over the course of 3 take out orders...

dom-152

28.08.2023 - 07:06

The pizza is hit and miss depending on who is making it. Aside from that, the food is pretty bad across the board. The subs are pathetic in taste, size and valu...

april-107

28.08.2023 - 07:06

We nhave been getting delivery from Anthony John's for quite a while. Lately, the food is bland, no taste. I had to add salt, garlic powder and basil to make sa...

keli-30

28.08.2023 - 07:06

First time trying Anthony John's. Props to be open on a Monday! Just stopped in for meatballs and garlic bread. I'm very particular about my meatballs. I like t...

metin-28

28.08.2023 - 07:06

We stopped by while we were on our way to nj, we had cheese pizza and garlic bread and penne ala vodka dinner which was perfect and tasty, looking forward to go...

Last update : 28.08.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near North Branford

olea - New Haven

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: New Haven (near North Branford), 39 High Street New Haven, CT 06510, 06510-2308, United States

"The New Years Eve tasting menu was divine special thanks for accommodating my allergies on such a busy evening. An elegant and delicious way to usher in 2018!"

##1 Seafood in New Haven

Details

#1 Seafood in New Haven

Doody's Totoket Inn

4.3

City: North Branford, 465 Foxon Rd N Branford, CT 06471-1140, North Branford, United States

"We went for their Thursday night special lasagna, but they were out of it by 615p. We ordered the potato skins and wings, which were both really good. French onion soup was just ok. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings"

##3 Fast Food in North Bra...

Details

#3 Fast Food in North Branford

Rosa Mina

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Ansonia (near North Branford), 384 E Main St, 06401-1904, Ansonia, United States

"Love this place! Owners are all friendly. Good people. My family and I usually order take out. The food is delicious! Best Italian restaurant in the valley! My favorite is their shrimp fradiavolo and tortellini bolognese! My kids love their pizzas!! Bon appetit!"

##5 Pizza in Ansonia

Details

#5 Pizza in Ansonia Italian American

Modern Apizza

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: New Haven (near North Branford), New Haven, 874 State St, 06511-7310, United States

"Really good pizza here. I went around 1pm on a weekday and it was surprisingly busy for a weekday but there was still plenty of seating available. I got a regular cheese pie and the taste started off pretty good but then the cheese began to harden and didn?t taste as good as the first few bites this is normal but I was surprised at how quickly it happened. The bake on the pizza also wasn?t as good as Sally?s and frank Pepe?s in my opinion. The service here is great though and this place is worth checking out just for the historic nature or the establishment"

##5 European in New Haven

Details

#5 European in New Haven European

Soul de Cuba

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: New Haven (near North Branford), New Haven, 283 Crown St, 06511-6654, United States

"The food was very delicious and Portions where great. Overall this food exceeded my expectations. Highly recommend this place."

##38 Cafés in New Haven

Details

#38 Cafés in New Haven

Ernie's Pizzeria

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: New Haven (near North Branford), 1279 Whalley Ave, New Haven, United States

"Had a few people recommend Ernie 's to me, so I met up with a friend here. The first thing we said to each other was Is it me or does it smell incredible outside?? I felt like I could taste the pizza in the parking lot. Did not disappoint"

##74 Vegetarian in New Hav...

Details

#74 Vegetarian in New Haven

Marco Polo Pizzeria Italian

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: New Haven (near North Branford), 55 Crown St, 06510, New Haven, United States

"Don't order from here. Order by grubhub and received MOLDY food. My wife tasted something and mentioned that it didn't taste right. With more accurate inspection there is mold. We threw away all the foods and I hope we're not sick with food poisoning."

##16 Pizza in New Haven

Details

#16 Pizza in New Haven Italian Salad

Jimmy's Apizza

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: Milford (near North Branford), 315 New Haven Ave,CT 06460-6647, United States, Milford

"Food at Jimmy's is always great. Pasta dishes and grinders are hearty and delicious. Best meat balls in town! Their pizza reminds me of my younger days in NYC NJ wonderful crispy crust, plenty of gooey cheese and tangy sauce, and fresh tasty meat and veggies toppings. Been eating Jimmy's food since they opened the takeout place in Pond Point Plaza."

##10 Seafood in Milford

Details

#10 Seafood in Milford

Laskara Restaurant

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Wallingford (near North Branford), 295 Parker Farms Rd Wallingford, CT 06492-2858, United States

"The food was amazing and so was the customer service. I enjoyed taking with the staff and the different foods I tried for the first time. Will definitely be going back and highly recommend!"

##2 Pizza in Wallingford

Details

#2 Pizza in Wallingford

Lorenzo's Ristorante Italiano, LLC

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: West Haven (near North Branford), 39 Elm St West Haven, CT 06516-3866, United States

At Lorenzo's Ristorante Italiano, LLC from West Haven it's possible to enjoy delicious vegetarian dishes, that were made without any animal meat or fish, Of course, you also have to try the fine burgers, that come with sides like fries, salads, or wedges offered. Furthermore, you'll find fine American dishes, like for instance burgers and grilled meat on the menu, You can also discover scrumptious South American dishes on the menu.

##29 Fast Food in West Hav...

Details

#29 Fast Food in West Haven Pizza