Oddfellows Ice Cream Co. - Nowatney

The average evaluation of 4.1 shows that the visitors have been very satisfied with the Oddfellows Ice Cream Co. so far.

What Tiffany Humphrey likes about Oddfellows Ice Cream Co.:
Run, don’t walk!!!! I’ve often walked by this ice cream shop but never stopped until today. I am so happy with my decision, and cannot wait to come back. There are so many great options to choose from, and they even have some for all of my Vegan people. I went with the triple scoop of mango cheesecake on a waffle cone…. OMG it was one of the best I’ve had. The atmosphere is welcoming and staff are amazinnnnng! Lookin... View all feedback.

What Jamillah Khan (jmillz) doesn't like about Oddfellows Ice Cream Co.:
We were so excited to finally try this spot out due to the reviews. However the taste of the ice cream wasnt that great as much as we tried to like it. Couldn’t finish the soft serve it just tasted watered down/icy. The cookie sandwich was ok however the cookie was so hard and not warmed up or anything. The taste was very much a let down. The service felt impatient and annoyed that we wanted to try some flavors. Not... View all feedback.