Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Erik Cohen likes about Bagel Boy:
Consistently fantastic year after year. By far the best bagels in the area, and I've tried them all. Expect a decent wait time during the busy morning and afternoon rush. Chocolate flavored coffee is incredible. View all feedback.
What Richard doesn't like about Bagel Boy:
(6-8-23 10:32am) Purposely ignored at front counter by short woman with curly hair. She did it twice and actually skipped me. Big thanks to the nice Hispanic man who finally saw me standing there to hand me my bag. Really hate to complain, but it looked blatant. Bagels delicious as always!!(3-5-23) Just picked up a few bagels and it was probably the best bagel I ever had!! They need to have a line/sign for “pick up only”, but the quality will make you forgot that minor inconvenience fast.
Good bagels. Long waiting time, but it's worth it. Wide selection of bagels and other breakfasts available. I ordered a garlic bagel with Jalapeno Omelette and it was delicious but very chaotic. Hot chocolate is good, but not great. My wife ordered a whole bagel with eggs and she thought it was delicious. Our order was wrong, but it was low, and we can tolerate the mistakes. The employees were very busy, but attentive to the customers. The bathroom was clean.
Best BAGELS NEW JERSEY! The egg all bagel with bacon scalion cream cheese is so delicious my favorite! They are always served fresh! I love this place!
Very good breakfast sandwiches. Salads and bagels. The staff is very helpful and friendly.
I just tried to leave this place from my regular place closer to home. Honestly, I haven't had a bagel so good since I lived in North Jersey 10 years ago. As long as I live in this area, this will be my baggage and breakfast place! Bagels are super fresh, airy and the perfect amount of Chewiness. You can also order online through your website. Make this place your regular place and you will not be disappointed!
Best bagels ever. I used to go to the original Brooklyn location in Sheepshead Bay. But I moved to South Jersey in 2020, when I retired, to be near my kids and grandkids. I missed their bagels but it's a 2+hour drive. So my daughter said let's try their NJ location. It was a little over and hour drive. It saved us over $30 in tolls. So it was like getting our bagels free! But most important, it's the same quality Bagel Boy bagels we were used to and missed so much.
Full Menu
Hot Drink
Omelettes
Breakfast
Sandwiches
Mixed Dishes
Sweet Crêpes
More information
QR-code link to the menu
