Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackThe average evaluation of 4.7 shows that the place is one of the favorites of all its guests.
What Mert likes about Popsy's Pizzeria:
Absolutely the best New York style pizza in Old Forge!!! News flash Old Forge (pizza capital of the world)...REAL PIZZA SAUCE IS NOT SWEET!!!!! Was born and lived 90% of my life in NY...Old Forge does NOT deserve the title of Pizza Capital . I 'm so grateful that Popseys is literally 4 doors from mine ???? View all feedback.
What Keith H doesn't like about Popsy's Pizzeria:
Ordered fries, fried pickles, and a Large stuffed crust extra cheese Supreme pizza. Came home it was all but Supreme. Tim personally delivered to me what I originally ordered, free of charge. Pizza was Very Good and the fried pickles were NICE sized appetizers. I will be back, highly recommended. Updated: 5-21-22 Ordered $70 worth of food. Always good. Can't complain. Make sure they verify your order. Didn't get my j... View all feedback.
The owner Tim Kane stole 4K dollars from me to smoke crack and shoot heroin. He refuses to pay me back. Anyone that orders from here has to worry about catching...
read moreAmazing. For a take out Pizzeria this place had really good pizza and i lived their wings and Cesar salad. Everything was fresh. They delivered to our hotel in...
read moreFull Menu
Here you'll find in addition to selected menus, a comprehensive drinks selection, and various dish categories. The menu is regularly expanded by customer recommendations and ingredients recommended by guests in a commendable way. The menu may be enriched on site by daily or weekly special offers.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
