What Toby Olsen likes about Tavern 23:
Outstanding food and service with a great atmosphere. Everyone who works there is so nice and professional and goes above and beyond to make the dining experience one you won’t soon forget. View all feedback.

What BamaRoth doesn't like about Tavern 23:
We ordered the calamari as an appetizer, it was chewy and over fried, we ordered two shots of patrone, it was definitely watered down. My friend ordered a burger, meh… I ordered a salad because nothing else looked good. The salad was all iceberg lettuce, and WAY too much dressing! We were there on a Friday, there were three tables total and the waitress barely came over… The price was astronomical for what we bought,... View all feedback.

Restaurantji
3.0 ★ from 2 reviews
sergia-tanis
28.02.2024 - 11:11

Not what use to be when they first opened menu getting worst and now new chief they say the worst friends also

j-d-mushroom3
28.02.2024 - 11:11

Excellent venue for a cocktail party. Drinks bites were perfect! Outdoor seating with a fire pit. Service was great.

Full Menu

The current menu card may be expanded on site to include seasonal specialties and weekly recommendations. In addition to a variety of meals, the menu also offers a diversity of beverages and typical house dishes. Additionally, the menu card also takes into account dishes and ingredients that have been positively highlighted by customers, even if these have not yet been listed.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Windham (near Preston-Potter Hollow), Ze Windham Wine Bar, 5369 State Route 23, Windham, NY, 12496, USA, Afghanistan
"100 stars for this place! We’re here for a bachelorette night. The outside was beautiful and cozy. The owner was super nice, and had great staff! The wine was absolutely amazing. Definitely wouldn’t mind coming back here for a date night. Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Outdoor Wine Bar"
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Tannersville (near Preston-Potter Hollow), 790 Co Rd 25, 12485, Tannersville, US, United States
Vegan Options, Accepts Credit Cards, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Windham CDP (near Preston-Potter Hollow), 5742 State Highway 23, Windham CDP, 12496, United States Of America
"Homemade soup was excellent. Chicken Orzo and I can never pass up a Gyro. It was fresh and tzatziki again homemade. Portions and prices are great. "
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Hunter (near Preston-Potter Hollow), 13 Scribner Hollow Rd, 12442, Hunter, US, United States
"We hosted a corporate retreat for 35 people at Scribner 's and were stunned by the helpfulness of everyone on staff, the beautiful settings (gorgeous scenery and lovely 'high-class rustic ' interior), the quality of the food and drinks, and thehelpful suggestions we received while planning our very particular event. We asked a lot of the Scribner 's team and theydelivered beautifully, staying flexible, available and communicative through the whole planning process and especially once wewere on site. Our group especially enjoyed having an activity in the beautiful garden, the no-cook appetizer and fermentationclass that Scribner 's organized, and the way the lodge facilitated both large group meetings as well as so many more privatesettings where our guests could have meetings or unwind in smaller groups. We struggled to organized transport for ourinternational guests but managed by working with several taxi companies in the area (also recommended by Scribners), so ifyou 're willing to put in a little effort on transport then Scribner 's will take care of literally everything else and yourentire group will love this venue! Thank you SO MUCH for your central role in making our retreat such a success, Kayleigh,Miranda, and the rest of the team!"
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Windham (near Preston-Potter Hollow), 5510 State Route 23, Windham I-12496-5803, United States
"Fantastic breakfast, many choices of omelettes great pancakes nice little Country Store almost like a small Cracker Barrel"