Reviews
Now, you have 12299 opinions from 10 website(s) at your disposal. The midpoint review for Carmelo's Italian is 4.7, denoting that this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests. Carmelo's, a highly recommended Italian restaurant, offers handmade authentic dishes. While some patrons encountered reservation issues and slow service, others praised the food and friendly staff. One customer celebrated their birthday with a special dessert, while another was impressed by the unique dishes and exceptional service. A mixed bag of experiences, but most diners appreciated the delicious food and welcoming ambiance.
Reviews from various websites
My favorite restaurant of all times. Everything is superb. Staff is friendly and they know their stuff. They do not rush you. Get the Bada Bing for an appetizer...
read moreI was treated to dinner there recently and it was outstanding. The food is authentic the menu has plenty of choices. Be aware that some items are served only in...
read moreDelightful dinner! Love their specialty Sacchettini-features pasta purses filled with pear cheeses drenched in the BEST Gorgonzola cream sauce accented with cri...
read moreFirst time eating here. The restaurant is beautiful has outdoor dining. You feel like you're in Italy. The food is beyond what one could imagine. Pasta is fresh...
read moreThe food was so yummy and my waiter, gianni was very nice!! I also loved the italian music in the background. Everything was just amazing here and i highly reco...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreI am in the local area to help with Hurricane Ian recovery. I stayed in a highly rated restaurant not far from my hotel in Punta Gorda a few days ago and bought...
read moreOur server Johnny was amazing. So a great, upscale, friendly personality and incredibly informed about the menu. He could even make excellent recommendations fo...
read moreMake sure you have a reservation to dine there. If it is important for you where you sit, you might want to double check with them that they have seating (insid...
read moreSERIOUS AUTHENTIC ITALIAN FOOD??????? ?? You can tell it's all handmade from the 1st bite. Reservations are highly recommended ??They were nicely FULL. The enti...
read moreIt was my 20th birthday and I am so happy I decided to spend it at Carmelo's. It was my first time here and I had the nicest server, She was so sweet with the b...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreMy favorite restaurant. Garden seating was comfortable even in the heat.
I usually order a pasta or seafood dish but felt like meat this time and ordered the signature Bocconcini a La Marsala, medallion fillet with green beans and ve...
read moreI have been to Carmelo's many times and usually love my meal and can't wait to go back. Tonight was a different story. My boyfriend and I made a reservation at...
read moreWe asked our waitress for recommendations and had a bruchetta as an appetizer. It had fig in it..It lived up to her description and was delicious. I had chicken...
read moreUPDATED- We met with friends for drinks. We decided to order a take away pizza and some drinks to go. They doubled charged us for the drinks. I didn't notice ti...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreThe service was excellent and the food was very good. I will definitely eat here again!
We had a nice time on the outdoor patio, which was empty. We enjoyed the fresh air, although the noise from the street was a bit loud.
Amazing food great service ambiance was great. Will definitely return
Band was 4 piece in courtyard and they were too loud for the space. Could not hold a conversation with our guests until they took a short break.
I had 3 friends fly in to visit. I had already had my reservations so I decided to keep them since we were eating outside. We had Chelsea a wonderful warm profe...
read more{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more