Reviews
Currently you have 1634 evaluation from 3 website(s) available. The average rating for Papa's Tomato Pies is 4.6 which means that this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests.
Reviews from various websites
We have half a must-cake with sausage and garlic and half regular with basil. Crispy crust with little chewing. Mustard cake side was best. The garlic was very...
read moreThis is my favorite pizza place in existence! The mustard pizza was just fantastic. The wings were strange. They were a little sweet/tangie and crispy. Not a ta...
read moreThin and crispy. Great sauce. Outstanding pizza. We also tried the mustard pie which was quite good as it adds just a hint of something different.
Old-school classic from Trenton. I had been eager to visit for a long time. Well worth the trip off the highway on our way from VA to Newark for the hockey game...
read moreI don't want to say this is the best pizza in NJ, but it is definitely one of the best pizzas in NJ. This sounds like a bold claim, but the mustard pie here is...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more