Villa Rustica - Rye Brook

What Sadie G likes about Villa Rustica:
Recently re discovered this restaurant and so glad I came back on a whim. Definitely was renovated at some point with a now modern look. Classic Italian American cuisine with generous portion. Food came out very hot, I couldn't even eat right away. The mussels were drowning in a delicious red sauce. We dipped the warm, toasted bread in the sauce rather than using butter no shame! View all feedback.

What Linda D doesn't like about Villa Rustica:
We did take out last night for the first time. How disappointing. The baked ziti looked liked warmed up leftovers. There was about a tablespoon of ricotta cheese in the whole dish and minimal mozzarella on top. We asked for some bread and the server said this doesn't come with bread and then threw a bag of two tiny slices of dried bread into the bag. Definitely not a repeat if for the attitude alone. Too bad. View all feedback.