Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What leo Kristen likes about New York Pizza:
Vegetarian options: They had a Gluten Free option for my kid was a bit expensive about $24 with tip but was delicious nonetheless. Parking: Parking was difficult, was able to find parking in the garage however eventually. Was about a 2 min walk. View all feedback.
What Majool doesn't like about New York Pizza:
This place is okay but there are other better pizza joints in downtown San Mateo. I found that the dough is inconsistent as it is sometimes might be too thick or too thin. Guess it depends on who is working there on that day. Would that being said. This place is located right next to a bar where you can take your pizza inside. View all feedback.
Pizza was great but not quite extra cheese as ordered. The manager on today has tremendous customer service skills very accountable. My single complaint is that the delivery driver did not follow my detailed instructions at all disturbed the front house owners. I hope to order again soon, but get a different delivery driver Xtra cheese as ordered, though the pie was pretty good, I must say.
Terrible service, I called for an order and an hour later I called again and they told me that the driver couldn't find the address and that he went to another address. They never called me to guide them to my house. I speak English, Spanish and their workers are racist. I did it again. another order and I spoke Spanish they hung up on me and they didn't answer again, my friend tried to call from her phone and they answered quickly if they don't have tolerance for clients they have to look for a new job everyone must love what they do. For my part, I will not return to New York pizza
Their pizza crust, sauce, and overall ratios are pretty bad. the two slices I got, it was like they fully baked the crust then added the toppings and baked it again, crunchier than a cracker. the pizza tastes like a lunchable pizza that someone left in the oven for too long.absolutely nothing like NY pizza and not really good by california standards either
Great local pizza joint for giant slices made to order. They are open late and always take care of their customers. Bonus being next to a bar! If you ask they will bring the pizza next door for you to enjoy with a nice cold beer. Vegetarian options: Lots of veggie options.
A late night snack really hit the spot and even though it was nearly time to close they made a delicious pie .
Full Menu
Drinks
Sides
Entrées
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
