Sea Star Cafe And Reviews (29)

Reviews

Menulist has collected all the reviews for Sea Star Cafe And from various portals to give you a transparent impression. Currently, there are 29 reviews from 1 website(s) available to you. The average rating for Sea Star Cafe And is 2.8 which means that that this restaurant has received mixed critics from its guests. Help our visitors with your review for this restaurant!.

Overall Total Score

2.8 out of 5

Average | 29 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Sea Star Cafe And from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (2.8 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in SANIBEL.

robert-b-lawyer7-flo

07.05.2024 - 15:35

What a terrible waste of a nice space. It was empty, so all we did was order 2 drinks. They didn't even get that right. They were awful. Someone take this place...

christopher-m-teache-6

07.05.2024 - 15:35

We came in here at 8pm on a Saturday and were the only people in the place. Drinks were fine but nothing special. We won't be back. 326/365

emilia-v-flower13

07.05.2024 - 15:35

When every other restaurant had an hour wait, we came here as it was in our hotel! Even though they were short-staffed, the waitress was very accommodating and...

allan-m-flower55

07.05.2024 - 15:35

We had dinner in this cafe during the first night of our stay in otherwise pleasant Sanibel Inn. The food was terrible small chunk of tasteless fish accompanied...

claudia-d-doctor61-s

07.05.2024 - 15:35

We had a great dinner at the sea star cafe. Started with a crab bisque follow by NY strip steak. My husband had the chicken masala substituted pasta for mash po...

Last update : 07.05.2024

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near SANIBEL

Joey's Custard

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: SANIBEL, 2467 Periwinkle Way, Sanibel, Florida, USA, 33957, 33957-3230, SANIBEL, United States

"So many choices! We got cones, cups, and shakes. Ice cream was really good, cute place and plenty of picnic tables to enjoy your treat!"

##1 Fast Food in SANIBEL

Details

#1 Fast Food in SANIBEL

Doc Ford's Rum Grille Ft. Myers Beach

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Fort Myers Beach (near SANIBEL), 708 Fishermans Wharf, 33931, Fort Myers Beach, United States

"Great atmosphere! Easily sat a party of seven. Prompt and friendly server. Incredible view. Lots of great drinks and great variety of menu. Shrimp and grits and Panko grouper were fabulous. Macadamia crusted group delicious and I loved the coconut rice melody. Clam chowder was incredible. Place can accommodate lots of guest. Parking is okay. Bathrooms located outside. Live music, retail, gift cards and good times to be had."

##2 Pizza in Fort Myers Be...

Details

#2 Pizza in Fort Myers Beach

Island Bistro Heidi's

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Fort Myers Beach (near SANIBEL), 2943 Estero Blvd, 33931-3552, Fort Myers Beach, United States

Takeout, Delivery, Terrace, Wheelchair Accessible

##1 Vegetarian in Fort Mye...

Details

#1 Vegetarian in Fort Myers Beach

El Sabor De Puebla

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Fort Myers (near SANIBEL), 16200 San Carlos Blvd, #140, Fort Myers, FL 33908, United States

"This place was terrible, the first thing was the chips were burnt and super hard and broken into small pieces , should have left then. The food arrived, mine plate was huge but hardly any rice or refried beans , the rice was fine but refried beans were absolutely the worse I ever tasted , the actual chimi was weirdest , hardest and tasteless one I have ever had , no sour cream or other flavorings you normally get. My friend both got there meals , totally burnt to crisp they said it was worse Mexican food they had ever had and I must agree , did I mention I have sick throwing all night and horrible heartburn . I did see other customers who ordered same food and looked good , but after this experience I couldn't never eat there again"

##2 Mexican in Fort Myers

Details

#2 Mexican in Fort Myers Lunch Coffee

Harold's

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Fort Myers (near SANIBEL), 15250 S Tamiami Trail #107, Fort Myers, USA, 33908, United States

"From the time we arrived until we exited all we can say is WOW. The host staff greeted us with smiling faces and seated us immediately at a lovely little table. From there we were greeted within a few moments and water was filled. Again all smiles. So far ...perfect. We were met by our server Heather. What a pro she is. Smiling face,again,and off to the wine list we went. We had the mushroom soup to begin along with the amazing bread. This is going very well as we realized that we were definitely on to a great start of our evening Delicious!!! My wife had the scallops and I opted for the bone in Ribeye....scallops were FANTASTIC.... melt down lol....Ribeye almost brought me to another world. PERFECT Medium. I can't remember the last time I have had a Ribeye so delicious.... THANK YOU! The place was busy with laughter and excitement along with a vibe of unexplainable warmth. The entire feeling is unmatched in our last few outings. Never did Harold's miss a beat. We actually saw the owner but didn't get a chance to talk as he made his way to various tables. Not an issue as he is obviously a bit busy. Tyler Carr GM) stopped over to introduce himself and we had a lovely discussion. We then decided to try the 2015 Viticgio Chianti. Once again, Heather is all about the experience and what a great choice. Loved the Chianti! After dinner we opted for the chocolate cake don't remember the name....too busy enjoying it). Long story short.... AMAZING EVERYTHING. This is a must try for everyone. Whether a glass of wine or a special evening GO....EAT.... ENJOY... you'll be back We will. Thank you for a wonderful evening and AMAZING EVERYTHING. ... Nick and Susan DeNoia Ft Myers. .."

##1 Seafood in Fort Myers

Details

#1 Seafood in Fort Myers European

Love Boat Ice Cream

4.9

Table booking

4.9

Table booking

City: Fort Myers (near SANIBEL), 16229 San Carols Blvd, Fort Myers, USA, 33908-3330, United States

Terrace, Takeout, Parking, Delivery

#Desserts

Details

Desserts Ice Cream Coffee Fish Wine

Sanibel Fish House

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: SANIBEL, 1523 Periwinkle Way, 33957-4513, SANIBEL, United States

"We never not stop at Sanibel Fish House when visiting Sanibel Island, our third visit this year. The welcome from Crystal was enthusiastic and attentive, as was the service from Thomas, our waiter. I had the special of the day, Pompano w/shrimp, and mywife had the blackened chicken with a house salad. The tuna bites appetizer is not to be missed."

##23 Pizza in SANIBEL

Details

#23 Pizza in SANIBEL Vegetarian