Shelter Island Craft Brewery Reviews (359)

So that you don't dive naively into a new culinary adventure, Menulist has compiled all the reviews for SHELTER ISLAND Craft Brewery from all important websites, so you can get a transparent picture. So far there are 359 reviews found on 7 pages. On average, Shelter Island Craft Brewery was rated 4. This means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help our visitors find the best spots and submit a review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4 out of 5

Impressive | 359 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Shelter Island Craft Brewery from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (4 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in SHELTER ISLAND.

allenfein

20.11.2023 - 06:32

Gave this a mediocre review three year’s ago because I could not find a beer that I liked. This time I found their Pilsner style fresh pour absolutely delicious...

lee

20.11.2023 - 06:32

Ok super disappointed. Walked a lot my way there from the ferry and … it was closed (on a Friday! . Bummed.

g-w-store51

20.11.2023 - 06:32

An amazing spot with great beer and wonderful staff and owner.

I was just driving around that corner of the island trying to find my way back to the ferry, when I run into this brewery, the bartenders were super relaxed and...

danielle-bremer

20.11.2023 - 06:32

Great tasting beers and great vibes! We will definitely be back here.

Last update : 20.11.2023

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near SHELTER ISLAND

Almond Bridgehampton

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: Bridgehampton (near SHELTER ISLAND), One Ocean RoadNY 11932, Bridgehampton, United States

"Delicious dinner and exceptional waitress. Unique menu and impressed that Sancerre wine is on tap! One of our favorite restaurants in the Hamptons."

##1 Fast Food in Bridgeham...

Details

#1 Fast Food in Bridgehampton

18 Bay

4.6

Online table booking

4.6

Online table booking

City: SHELTER ISLAND, 23 North Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States

"Chefs Elizabeth and Adam and front of house manager and sommelier Jimmy continue to elevate 18 Bay to greater heights. My take is always that I could eat the appetizer plate and leave totally satisfied. The creativity and execution of the four elements surpasses what one would experience in an entire meal elsewhere. Jimmy has curated a terrific selection of wines ALL available by the glass Why eat anywhere else in the Hamptons. Bravi!!!"

##1 Fast Food in SHELTER I...

Details

#1 Fast Food in SHELTER ISLAND Pizza

Maria's Kitchen

4.7

Online table booking

4.7

Online table booking

City: SHELTER ISLAND, 55 N Ferry Rd (at Jaspa Rd), Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States

TV, Accepts Credit Cards, Takeout, Delivery

##1 Mexican in SHELTER ISL...

Details

#1 Mexican in SHELTER ISLAND

Vine Street Cafe

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: SHELTER ISLAND, 41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States

"Disappoint. at the visit of the eastern end of li we were delighted to taste this restaurant. as a restaurant owner and chef for 30 years I was pleased to see chateaubriand on the menu. the joy stopped when the dinner came for 2. what we received was 5 discs filet mignon on a cold plate, with the soße straight out of the refrigerator. it came with 1 order of the pommes. every chateaubriand I have ever eaten with kartoffels and carrots, and hot kies or demi glacé. when we informed the server, he said that they serve the sauce ice cream cold. everything I can say is euwwww. the flesh was tender when they like cold meat with a temperate sauce. all for $92.00! the manager I...read more"

##2 Fast Food in SHELTER I...

Details

#2 Fast Food in SHELTER ISLAND

The Halyard At Sound View

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: GREENPORT (near SHELTER ISLAND), 58775 Route 48, GREENPORT, United States

"The Halyard is a large restaurant with multiple dining areas. We were seated in the older section with red wood paneling on the walls and ceiling as if on an old ship. It was great. The newer dining areas give the feeling of dining in a cafeteria. If you have the option, request to eat in the older section. The ship like ambiance on the water's edge just as the sun set. Stunning setting hard to beat this anywhere."

##3 Seafood in GREENPORT

Details

#3 Seafood in GREENPORT American

North Fork Table & Inn

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Southold (near SHELTER ISLAND), North Fork & Shelter Island, 57225 Main Rd, 11971-4750, Southold, United States

"This was a perfect meal. Great craft cocktails. Every dish was prepared superbly.the fluke crude stood out as especially great. The redesign of the interior by the new ownership worked well. Considering the superb quality the pricing was quite fair.Service was excellent. The new owners as of had big shoes to fill , and they have filled them very well indeed. There is no restaurant on the North Fork that even comes close to this one, and that's saying a lot"

##4 Cafés in Southold

Details

#4 Cafés in Southold American

Cove Hollow Tavern

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: East Hampton North (near SHELTER ISLAND), 85 Montauk HwyNY 11937, East Hampton North, United States

"Great food, squid pasta was delicious. Sah at the bar and had great service from Barmann. Definitely be back."

##5 Seafood in East Hampto...

Details

#5 Seafood in East Hampton North

MJ Dowling's

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: SAG HARBOR (near SHELTER ISLAND), 3360 Noyac RdNY 11963, SAG HARBOR, United States

"Always get a great meal at Dowlings! Go with their specials! They are always something to rave about!!"

##7 Seafood in SAG HARBOR

Details

#7 Seafood in SAG HARBOR American

Fresno

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: East Hampton North (near SHELTER ISLAND), 8 Fresno PlaceNY 11937, East Hampton North, United States

"The food was good and service was great! Whom for my birthday and they made it special!"

##14 Pizza in East Hampton...

Details

#14 Pizza in East Hampton North

Il Capuccino

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: SAG HARBOR (near SHELTER ISLAND), 30 Madison St,NY 11963-4418, United States, SAG HARBOR

"The garlic rolls are addictive, I had 3!! The split pea soup, yum but the codfish special was ok, great piece of fish, not knocking that but it was missing some flavor. Now others may disagree, my taste buds have been ruined with spicy foods so I always need a huge burst of flavor, but still delicious. Plus the hostesses and our server were great! Will definitely come back oh and I don't typically eat meat but did try a bite of the Riley and it was pretty damn good. It's hard to find good red meat in America!"

##5 Seafood in SAG HARBOR

Details

#5 Seafood in SAG HARBOR Pizza