Amy's Pizza Reviews (536)

Reviews

At present, there are 536 ratings available from 4 website(s). The mean score for Amy's Pizza is 4.4, implying that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant.

Overall Total Score

4.4 out of 5

Impressive | 536 reviews

Reviews from various websites

xhauck-mushroom49

11.05.2023 - 08:40

The first time to eat here. I had a Phlly Beef Sub and definitely the best I ever had! Very recommended.

blockman-student3

11.05.2023 - 08:40

The best pizza found in Shipshewana when I found Amys Pizza. Great friendly staff and great pizza!

11.05.2023 - 08:40

I love Amys pizza friendly, clean, and a great place for date nights and they have Wi-Fi. Pizzaburgers are the best in town.

angus-hodkiewicz

11.05.2023 - 08:40

Great food, reasonable prices! I had the Stromboli, my wife had the pizza burger and we shared the garlic cheesie bread. Awesome

rnienow-grass384

11.05.2023 - 08:40

The great reviews here did not disappoint! We were staying in a cabin with no kitchen, so we had to get all of our meals in town. I called for carry out pizza....

Last update : 11.05.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Shipshewana

Blue Gate And Bakery

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: Shipshewana, 195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana I-46565, United States

"It was an awesome experience. Will definitely return!!"

##10 Vegetarian in Shipshe...

#10 Vegetarian in Shipshewana

Blue Gate Bakery

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: Shipshewana, 195 N Van Buren St, Shipshewana, United States Of America

"The buffet is awesome! There is a salad bar, a pie bar and a hot table, two soups. Some items may change daily. It was a Saturday, fried shrimp and me..."

Bakery Cheese Sandwiches Meat Chicken

Souper Brew

4.7

Menu

Table booking

4.7

Menu

Table booking

City: Middlebury (near Shipshewana), 830 S Main St, Middlebury I-46540-7005, United States

"Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

Salad Lunch American North American

Jaywalker Restaurant

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: White Pigeon (near Shipshewana), 10188 US Highway 12 White Pigeon, MI 49099-9143, United States

"Food and service were excellent"

Tradamerican Burgers Burger American

The Country Table

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: White Pigeon (near Shipshewana), 714 W Chicago RdMI 490999166, White Pigeon, United States

"Service: Dine in Meal type: Breakfast Price per person: $10–20"

#Breakfast-brunch

Breakfast-brunch Diners American

Evan's Sidewalk Cafe

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: Bristol (near Shipshewana), 216 E Vistula St, 46507, Bristol, US, 46507-8613, United States

"Great eating? always busy with customers?"

French Toast American

Wedgewood Brewing Company

4.7

Menu

Table booking

4.7

Menu

Table booking

City: Middlebury (near Shipshewana), 129 Orpha Dr Unit B, 46540, Middlebury, US, United States

"Great smash burgers, brews, and live music. Super friendly staff."

Burgers Pubs Cheese Waffles Chicken

Iannarelli's Italian Restaurant

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: Howe (near Shipshewana), 405 Third St Howe, IN 46746-9811, United States

"Excellent food and service. Reliable fair prices."

Italian Soup Pasta Desserts Salad

The Hilltop

4.4

Menu

4.4

Menu

City: Middlebury (near Shipshewana), 300 Wayne St, Middlebury I-46540-9263, United States

"Very pleasant and delicious food Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

American Breakfast Lunch Coffee

White Pigeon Inn

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: White Pigeon (near Shipshewana), 110 W Chicago Rd, White Pigeon, MI 49099, United States

"Thursday burger special for $5 was awesome as always"

Pizza Burgers Cheese Sandwiches Pub