Reviews
What evelyn santiago doesn't like about The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza:
I went for my son’s birthday dinner 3 of us. Sat July 13. The food was ok. I was so excited about going tell my son. The owner comes by. We tell him we are happy with our meal. We valet the car. We leave drive off. I get out the car. The key Lights goes on. The kid that was doing valet forgot to give my husband the car. My husband call the restaurant tells them I want to speak to the owner. He doesn’t get on the phon... View all feedback. What Tyler Douglas likes about The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza:
As a pizza lover, bartender at Deninos, and a Staten Island Local, Goodfellas keeps up with the pack and is a hidden gem like most restaurants in the forgotten borough. Pizza is delicious!! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Omg! We are Florida residents passing through the area and wanted to try real Staten Island pizza. Everyone told us the same thing. Go to Goodfella's! We arrive...
read moreLoved the pizza. The cucumber cooler was perfect for a nice cool or hot day. It went perfectly with our pizza. The crust was on point, it was nice and crispy.
really nice food, especially the pizza!!! Amazing service from the managers Scott, and our waiter Angelina was so nice and welcoming. Would come back
This was our first time at this location! Our Seever was George and he was FANTASTIC- personable and just made the experience even better! The food was absolute...
read moreOne of the best restaurants with delicious food and the best valet company (Premier Valet). Dana’s espresso martinis are top tier
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreIve been going here since i was a kid. Best pizza hands down. The Alla Vodka pizza, the calama, the baked clams, all to die for.
AMAZING. Some of the best pizza I ever had. The vodka pizza is worth the trip itself. If you haven’t been here yet you are missing out.
As a pizza lover, bartender at Deninos, and a Staten Island Local, Goodfellas keeps up with the pack and is a hidden gem like most restaurants in the forgotten...
read moreThis is my favorite pizza on the planet. I found the now closed Amboy rd location many years ago while living in Staten Island, and even though I've long since...
read moreI've had take out from here for the last 20 years and the food is excellent! As a change of pace my husband and I had dinner here last night for the first time...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more