Reviews
So that you don't dive naively into a new culinary adventure, Menulist has compiled all the evaluations for Papa Luigi's from different websites, so you can get a comprehensive picture. So far there are 1090 evaluations found on 11 pages. On average, Papa Luigi's was rated 4.5. This means that this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests. Help other guests find the best spots and submit a review through our rating system.
Reviews from various websites
All reviews for Papa Luigi's from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (4.5 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Sutton West.
Yelp
Papa Luigi's is a great little storefront restaurant right on High St in Sutton Always clean and fresh Costas and family are doing a fantastic job of serving fr...
read moreHistoric spot.... Great pizza. Too bad it further than I like to travel for a meal. Best service for take out
I was working out of Sutton and found this on Maps . So happy I went . The pictures will show the beauty of their food and they also own a bakery the cookies an...
read morePAPA LUIGIS PIZZA IS THE BEST!!! Nice family restaurant good quality food/service A definite hidden jem in Georgina
The best eggs Benny made on a beautiful sourdough bread! I've been on the pricey side, but I actually get two meals out of it.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more
Tripadvisor
Google
Restaurantguru
INT Restaurants
Restaurantji
Findmeglutenfree
Good Rated Restaurants near Sutton West
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
City: Innisfil (near Sutton West), 2383 25 Sideroad, Innisfil, Ontario L9S 2G3, Canada, L9S2G3
Seating, Kids, Parking, Wifi
4.4
Menu
Online table booking
4.4
Menu
Online table booking
City: York (near Sutton West), 20815 Dalton Road, Georgina, Ontario, Canada, L0E1R0, York
"This restaurant specializes in specialty burgers. Fresh ground beef never frozen and ground on site prepared fresh. Fries are cut on site and are also fresh. Very trendy inside and is reminiscent of a downtown Toronto restaurant. Isn't cheap per se for a burger but is definitely worth it! Don't waste your time or money going through a typical fast food drive through to get a stale bun and frozen patty and fries - spend a few bucks more and get great food!"
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
City: Georgina (near Sutton West), 26092 Highway 48, Sutton, Georgina, Ontario L0E 1R0, Canada, L0E1R0
"Not fancy but good reasonably priced comfort food. Early bird dinner specials, great breakfasts, stop in for dessert. Worth a visit"
4.4
Menu
Online table booking
4.4
Menu
Online table booking
City: York (near Sutton West), 24018 Woodbine Ave | Unit 5, Georgina, Ontario L4P 3E9, Canada, L4P2P8, York
"Naked wings was delicious, sweet thing wings are a must with loaded fries! Cathy was so kind and helpful. 10/10 will return!"
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
City: Innisfil (near Sutton West), 261 Sunseeker Ave, Innisfil, Canada
"Had a horrible experience dining here today. Food was alright but we definitely received a lot of discrimination unlike I 've ever experienced before. Came here for lunch today with my husband and son(15 months) there was one server and one guy at the bar, seems like the manager. We were the first table there for lunch and 3 more came in during our time there. During our meal I felt the guy at the bar glaring over at us, I get that no one likes a screaming baby but my son only raised his voice a few times and when he did we would immediately try to calm him down. After we had paid and was preparing to leave, the server brought us some paper towels and said for your mess ummm ok... at this point I actually had already cleaned everything that was spilled on the table and essentially no food garbage was left, on the floor there was a few dropped napkins and a fork. I went to the washroom and when I got back I see the guy/manager standing right next to my table where my husband and son was getting dressed and he was looking at our table shaking his head then walked off as I approached. Is this standard restaurant practice to judge guests right in front of their face?? And as I was walking out the door he said to me thanks for cleaning up I 'm left wondering are you mocking me? Is this really necessary? Is it because I 'm Chinese? Because I have a baby? This sarcasm was really unnecessary, I get parents are responsible for their baby and I try to do my part to a certain extent but do you need treat your customers line this? Is not like I didn 't tip, we gave a standard 15%. Definitely left this place feeling uneasy."
4.5
Menu
Online table booking
4.5
Menu
Online table booking
City: Georgina (near Sutton West), 4- West, 7751 Black River Rd, Georgina, Canada
"Great place with a menu that offers some interesting twists on the classics. So nice to sit on the patio in the summer. My one request is to bring back the chicken popper sandwich!"
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
City: Keswick (near Sutton West), 213 The Queensway S, Keswick, Georgina, Ontario L4P 2A7, Canada, L4P2N7
"You can't find better value and taste for miles. Don't miss this local treasure."
4.4
Menu
Online table booking
4.4
Menu
Online table booking
City: Innisfil (near Sutton West), 7905 Yonge St, Innisfil, Ontario L9S 1K9, Canada, L9S1K9
Waitstaff, Wheelchair Accessible, Kids, Parking Available
4.6
Menu
Online table booking
4.6
Menu
Online table booking
City: Innisfil (near Sutton West), 261 Sunseeker AvenueON L9S 0J7, Innisfil, Canada
"Environment was okay, the food was not as good as expected, especially the oyster. Overall it was a bit pricy. With a price like that I would say you can find a better place."
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
4.3
Menu
Online table booking
City: Innisfil (near Sutton West), 7975 Yonge Street 3A 3B, L9S 1L2, Innisfil, Canada, L9S 1A8
"What an absolute nightmare of a time. Several of my girlfriends went for their 80/90's dance....it was a joke. From the moment we walked in and try to have someone greet us at the door. The usual bar tender Nicole wasn't working. someone horrible who we are pretty sure did not have her smart serve Melissa was the bar tender for the night. She messed up our drink orders right off the get go. (insert huge eye roll Then we wanted to ordered some food, while I was waiting my turn to place an order. The older man (Bob? comes out from the kitchen and says NO more F ing salads...seriously. I was standing there. Melissa never said a word. Not to him or anyone standing at the bar. We never did end up placing a food order as we were scared it would have been spat in or dropped on the floor. Whatever horrible experience. If it hadn't been for Steve (fantastic DJ we would have left and gone downtown Barrie to The Queens to dance. At least we would have had a better licenced serve and able to order food. If you go, think again. As I truly hope you don't have the same experience. Oh and it looks like now the restaurant is closed. Interesting, as I know the owner was now trying to sell it. But he took it off the market. Guess the constant complaints finally had to close down."