Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What chaz mitchell likes about Colby's Ice Cream Bake Shop:
I met the owner operator at a fair or festival in Irondequoit, NY. The pie we were given was a sugar free apple pie. The pie was delicious and I would definitely recommend them to others. I would like to thank the owner for supporting our troops. Beat Navy! Vegetarian options: The pies are vegetarian Dietary restrictions: N/A Kid-friendliness: N/A View all feedback.
What G B doesn't like about Colby's Ice Cream Bake Shop:
I called and spoke with manager to report my extreme dissatisfaction with baked goods. I had extremely soggy chocolate cannolis, an apple turnover filled with canned apple pie filling, and an apple crumb pie that was wet and raw on top. I could tell that none of these items were actually made on premises and manager confirmed this. No one offered me a refund. View all feedback.
I am a frequent customer and the service has always been exceptional. We stopped five minutes before closing today but were welcomed and got our ice cream. We were sitting outside enjoying our treats a little after closing when a little old lady walked to the door but saw the closed sign, so she turned back to her car. One of the young men working there came running out to say they can still take her order!! She happily got her ice cream from a very upstanding young man that was on duty and cared enough to take care of a customer! VERY IMPRESSIVE!!!
If you are near 251 and W. Henrietta Rd, this is a must stop place. Great BBQ as well as a bakery. Pies, cookies, Danish, and all kinds of ice cream! You gotta tried it.
Love this place, good food and baked goods. Love the pies and ready to go meals that are reasonably priced. I recently purchased the caramel apple crumb cake and it was delicious. Everything is well stocked and well kept. I stop here a few times per month and can only say good things about my own personal experience. I will say the admins interactions on lower rated posts and people with differing opinions are defensive questionable ?
Good service here! They nicely accommodated our 21 school kids plus adults. Ice-cream was delicious!
We are looking forward to coming here often in the summer. Lots of tasty treats!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
