Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Penny Hill Subs:
This is a nice, clean establishment, family owned and run. The staff is friendly and personable, always ready to accommodate your order. I ordered an Italian sub. The ingredients were top notch and it reminded me of the nice versions of Italian subs I could find in Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island NY. I wanted to go back and take some photos for the review, as well as try a different item from the menu. However, each... View all feedback.
This is a nice, clean establishment, family owned and run. The staff is friendly and personable, always ready to accommodate your order. I ordered an Italian sub. The ingredients were top notch and it reminded me of the nice versions of Italian subs I could find in Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island NY. I wanted to go back and take some photos for the review, as well as try a different item from the menu. However, each time I tried to go back it was closed. One day I even called first, but neglected to ask if they would be open until 3. I think Google maps hours are incorrect, or hours are limited due to Memorial Day week. Either case clarification would be nice so people do not waste their time. It gets a 4 for that. Otherwise a 5.
As a former NJ native I can tell you that their subs taste like ' home ' . They have a Cuban sandwich that puts any other to shame. If you 're on a health kick they make the most amazing salads that are fresh and filling, if not they have delicious cup cakes. You 're greeted with beautiful warm smiles EVERY time you enter. What 's not to love?
Delicious, fresh and friendly! Annabelle and her staff are smiley and sweet and attentive! Salads are fresh, baked goods are dangerously good and the lamb gyro with creamy tsatziki sauce is SO flavorful! Such a great new addition to Miracle Mile!
I've been going to this place all my life. I even took my baby there on the way home from the hospital. I probably have kind of a tummy on me because I can't stop eating it. It closed and reopened during Covid and got rid of my favorite sandwich, the Rancher, but they have a great menu otherwise, so there's still lots to choose from. Maybe they surprise me and bring the Rancher back on a special day and they're just holding out to build the tasty anticipation. The other thing is that they are WAY generous with the meat. It'll be hard to eat a large even for big boys like me.
My family and I totally enjoy the subs. We believe the bread makes the difference. Wish I knew where to buy the bread. Not once has anyone complained about the quality of the food. It's always great Basia
More information
QR-code link to the menu
