Simply Sinful Homemade Ice Cream

Within the category Cafés, this place is considered one of the best in Village of Allegany ohi꞉yoʾ, and based on the average assessment of 4.8, it's likely one of the favorite restaurants of its guests.

What Beth J likes about Simply Sinful Homemade Ice Cream:
My husband and I decided to stop for dessert after dinner tonight at Simply Sinful In Allegany. It was our first time but definitely won't be our last! The owners (we assume) were so nice and helpful! They didn't mind our questions at all! The ice cream was delicious-I highly recommended the chocolate covered cherry and peanut butter snickers! We bought a pint of the alcohol ice cream home for our collage boy and his... View all feedback.

What Tim M doesn't like about Simply Sinful Homemade Ice Cream:
We had heard good things about the ice cream, so we figured we would try it. Said Tim is minimal, prices high. We both ended up sick an hour later, throwing up and feeling sick for the next day. Posted it on FB and a bunch of people replied that the same thing happened to them. They said that the building is rat infested and the landlord won't do anything about it. Health department needs to look into this. Avoid unt... View all feedback.