Reviews
What Judy P doesn't like about The Bake Shop Eatery:
Not impressed. I miss the owner making my food. I got a calzone that is more dough than filling, and the dough is raw. The sauce tastes like it came from a can and they dumped Italian seasoning on top. The young worker who was obviously in charge by her dissatisfaction with her disgusted look and body language to the young lady taking my money was certainly not what I have ever saw. I hope the owner comes back and re... View all feedback. What Terri G likes about The Bake Shop Eatery:
Great reason to get off the highway and have lunch. Homemade baked goods, great sandwiches and salads in a bread bowl which is made to order. Excellent customer service. More to this place then meets the eye. Definitely worth a try. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Excellent food! Many different options, subs, pizza, panini's, and pastries! Everything i've ever had here was flavorful and at a great price!
Good prices. Fried dough cooked perfect. Gluten free pizza and fresh baked cookies and pastries. Delivery within 7 miles of the Village of Mexico.
Not impressed. I miss the owner making my food. I got a calzone that is more dough than filling, and the dough is raw. The sauce tastes like it came from a can...
read moreWhen we first started going to this pizzeria it was so delicious..last few orders...well, not so much. They were the best pizza in town. Also, the staff looked...
read moreVery disappointed! Food quality was bad. So many better options for pizza in Mexico, NY.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more