The Milk Pail Reviews (116)

Good feedback only

Bad feedback only

Reviews

Currently, you have 116 ratings from 4 website(s) on hand. The midpoint valuation for The Milk Pail is 3.7, this indicates the vast majority of its guests was satisfied with its service.

Overall Total Score

3.7 out of 5

Very good | 116 reviews

Reviews from various websites

cute small market, bought some nice cheese, soppresa and bar beefe

large selection of items, somewhat overpriced. I have expected more options from cheese. I have a plan that was not disappointed!

Everything is fresh and tastes great. A little on the expensive side.

I had the best pfirsich cake, so delicious soft cookies, and top-off with coffee smoothie.

Been going to the Milk Pail for 20 years. Jennifer knows us as the Gals who come on Sunday of Columbus day weekend. Always have a great time the apples never ev...

Last update : 18.09.2022

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near WATER MILL

Almond Bridgehampton

4.8

Menu

Table booking

4.8

Menu

Table booking

City: Bridgehampton (near WATER MILL), One Ocean RoadNY 11932, Bridgehampton, United States

"We had the burger special which was great! Terrific service."

##1 European in Bridgehamp...

#1 European in Bridgehampton

The Plaza Cafe

4.6

Menu

Table booking

4.6

Menu

Table booking

City: Southampton (near WATER MILL), 61 Hill StreetNY 11968, Southampton, United States

"Excellent food prepared beautifully. Great deal at price serving"

##7 Fast Food in Southampt...

#7 Fast Food in Southampton Seafood

Main Road Biscuit Co.

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: Jamesport (near WATER MILL), 1601 Main Rd, 11947, Jamesport, US, United States

"Fast service great eating and affordable!"

##3 European in Jamesport

#3 European in Jamesport

Saaz

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: Southampton (near WATER MILL), 1746 County Road 39, Southampton I-11968-5204, United States

"Good Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##2 Vegetarian in Southamp...

#2 Vegetarian in Southampton Indian

Canal Cafe

4.3

Menu

4.3

Menu

City: Hampton Bays (near WATER MILL), 44 Newtown Rd, Hampton Bays I-11946-1432, United States

"Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4"

##22 Vegetarian in Hampton...

#22 Vegetarian in Hampton Bays

Rolling In Dough Pizza

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: GREENPORT (near WATER MILL), 308 Main St, 11944, Greenport, US, GREENPORT, United States

"Pizza was incredible. Staff was helpful and professional."

##2 Pizza in GREENPORT

#2 Pizza in GREENPORT Fast Food

Cappelletti Take Out

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: SAG HARBOR (near WATER MILL), 3284 Noyack Rd, Sag Harbor, USA, SAG HARBOR, United States

"Everything ok. Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5"

##5 Seafood in SAG HARBOR

#5 Seafood in SAG HARBOR

Dopo Buttero

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: East Hampton North (near WATER MILL), 31 Race Lane, Village Of East Hampton, 11937, United States Of America, 11937-2431, East Hampton North

"Priz fixe was great deal.. good portions.. restaurant is lovely"

##14 Pizza in East Hampton...

#14 Pizza in East Hampton North

Dock House

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: SAG HARBOR (near WATER MILL), Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, 11963, United States Of America, SAG HARBOR

"Delicious fresh seafood. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##3 Seafood in SAG HARBOR

#3 Seafood in SAG HARBOR American

Sophie's Rest

4.6

Menu

Table booking

4.6

Menu

Table booking

City: Southold (near WATER MILL), 11971 Southold, United States

"Welcoming atmosphere, fantastic staff, great company."

##6 Seafood in Southold

#6 Seafood in Southold Pizza Cafés