Old Yarmouth Inn Reviews (5728)

A restaurant without a rating is almost like a beer garden without a guest. Menulist has collected all reviews for Old Yarmouth Inn so you can get a picture based on the opinions of other visitors. So far, there are 5728 opinions found on 8 pages. The average rating for Old Yarmouth Inn is 4.6, which means this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests. Help other guests with your review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4.6 out of 5

Outstanding | 5728 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Old Yarmouth Inn from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (4.6 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Yarmouth.

After my server Joe's recommendation, I tried the Cape Cod-Bier Battery Fish Chips and they were amazing!! I loved the atmosphere, the service was excellent, an...

The staff was super friendly and accommodated a big party very well. The buffet had a nice variety and our server was attentive and fast to fix missing drinks o...

The cape could not leave without real seafood. Had the filled lobsters and shells casino and was not disappointed! Staff and service were great and very friendl...

This was my third time at dinner in the Inn, our little party reserved place at the pub. It was very lively with cartridges and we sat in a small table a few fe...

Had another wonderful meal at the Old Yarmouth Inn. My wife ordered clam chowder, but found it to be too salty for her taste {we hardly ever cook with salt). Ou...

Last update : 20.04.2023

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near Yarmouth

Caffe Gelato Bertini

4.9

Online table booking

4.9

Online table booking

City: South Yarmouth (near Yarmouth), 46 South Street, South Yarmouth I-02664, United States

"Hands down, the best gelato on Cape Cod. The word ambrosial fits. The lemon cream recipe is the pure heaven. Many parking spaces and outdoor and indoor seating. So an amazing place for some delicious treats."

##1 Pizza in South Yarmout...

Details

#1 Pizza in South Yarmouth Italian

The Ocean House Cape Cod

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: Dennis Port (near Yarmouth), 02639 Dennis Port, United States

"It was a lovely way to close out the season. Our waitress was AWESOME as were the food and cocktails. Enjoy your time off and see you next season, we think table 21 is our new favorite. Francine Rob"

##1 Seafood in Dennis Port

Details

#1 Seafood in Dennis Port

Clean Slate Eatery

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: WEST DENNIS (near Yarmouth), 702 Main St, West Dennis, Massachusetts, USA, 02670, WEST DENNIS, United States

Takeaway, Parking, Accepts Credit Cards, Takeout

##2 Vegetarian in WEST DEN...

Details

#2 Vegetarian in WEST DENNIS

Island Cafe Grill

4.8

Online table booking

4.8

Online table booking

City: Barnstable (near Yarmouth), 251 Iyannough Rd, Barnstable, USA, 02601-2032, United States

"Wonderful restaurant. We were welcomed by the owner who was so warm and friendly! Food is delicious. I had the jerk chicken wrap with lettuce , tomatoes and a delicious pineapple salsa!! Well done! My wife had the fish and chips. Both were fresh.. the fish and fries were crispy and the Cole slaw was creamy and well balanced. We Overheard the people at next table say that the burgers they had were the best ever! Great service and all the staff was so friendly and made you feel welcome. Five star plus! Highly recommend the Island Cafe and Grill. We’ll definitely be back!!"

##3 European in Barnstable

Details

#3 European in Barnstable European

Inaho Japanese

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Yarmouth, 157 MA-6A, Yarmouth, USA, 02675, United States

"Eating is in order fresh, and competently prepared and presented. However, I find most employees quite unfriendly. Last time I was eating there, I asked for a place at the bar, where only another one was fed in gas. my waiter has assigned me a place on the door where he was scarf and generally unpleasant. I had to sneak in and felt uncomfortable. but when another waiter noticed my discomfort, he pulled me on two places where the things were much better. my latest experience: I ordered on the phone from the menu on their website for a pickup. the price was listed at $155. shortly before I went to pick up, I got a call from them and told me that the price was increased with immediate effect to $175 and that they would add 18% service fee. the ton of the lady on the phone was short and rude. I canceled my order. in future I will take my business after misaki in hyannis."

##4 Seafood in Yarmouth

Details

#4 Seafood in Yarmouth Cafés Asiatic

The Jerk Cafe

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Yarmouth, 1319A MA-28, Yarmouth, USA, United States

"Every time I come here, it's always amazing to eat. I get in the rule the jerk, it has amazing taste, always perfectly cooked, never any rough parts of huh in there. chef shrimpy is a very nice man and there are always positive vibes when he sings as he cooks. my favorite part to come here is in the position to see him cook. this has become one of my favorite restaurants."

##1 Seafood in Yarmouth

Details

#1 Seafood in Yarmouth Cafés

Grill 43

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: YARMOUTH PORT (near Yarmouth), 43 Main St, 02675, YARMOUTH PORT, United States

"Friendly service, great presentation delicious unique foods. Happy to park with others as we arrived and left again. I also love watching the pizza chef."

##2 Fast Food in YARMOUTH...

Details

#2 Fast Food in YARMOUTH PORT

Naukabout Brewery And Taproom

4.5

Online table booking

4.5

Online table booking

City: Mashpee (near Yarmouth), 13 Lake Ave, 02649, Mashpee, US, United States

"This is a beautiful brewery with lots of outdoor seating and good beers. the vibe is casual and the beertenders were very friendly. there were just a couple beers that i really liked but they have plenty of ppl pleasers."

##5 Pizza in Mashpee

Details

#5 Pizza in Mashpee

Cape Cod Creamery

4.7

Online table booking

4.7

Online table booking

City: South Yarmouth (near Yarmouth), 5 Theater Colony Rd, South Yarmouth I-02664-4483, United States

"Pretty good ice cream! Some of the flavors are really lacking on fillings though, like the cookie dough, black cherry and mud pie. By cookie dough had one small bite inside. Also their waffle cones sell our super quick. Went twice this week after 7pm and both times they didn’t have any."

#American

Details

American Ice Cream Drinks Gelato