Lake Simcoe Arms Pub & Restaurant

In the category Seafood, this restaurant is listed among the best in York, and based on the average evaluation of 4, Lake Simcoe Arms Pub & Restaurant has so far greatly satisfied its customers.

What User likes about Lake Simcoe Arms Pub & Restaurant:
We recently attended a wedding reception upstairs at the Lake Simcoe Arms. A very nice and intimate venue for such an event. Nice atmosphere and we were well looked after by staff. My husband had ordered the prime rib and said it was very good and lots of food. I had chosen the chicken and was a little surprised how sparse my plate looked. The chicken was delicious but there was not much of it or of the vegetables or... View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about Lake Simcoe Arms Pub & Restaurant:
Things started off well enough, but when I received my roast beef dinner which I had requested 'medium rare', I received well-done. No pink visible at all. While realize there is some variance as to what constitutes 'medium rare', this wasn't medium rare. When I sent it back, politely, it was returned with the explanation, 'this all was available from the kitchen and I would have to accept it'. No admission that this... View all feedback.