Goodfella's Pizzeria Reviews (37)

Reviews

A restaurant without a rating is almost like a beer garden without a guest. Menulist has collected all reviews for Goodfella's Pizzeria so you can get an impression based on the opinions of other customers. So far, there are 37 reviews found on 1 pages. The average rating for Goodfella's Pizzeria is 4.6, which means this restaurant is incredibly well regarded by its guests. Help other guests with your review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4.6 out of 5

Outstanding | 37 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Goodfella's Pizzeria from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (4.6 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Afton.

nate-michaels-2

24.01.2024 - 13:47

Pretty darn good pizza. Give it a try and help a local business.

mark-mathews-2

24.01.2024 - 13:47

Food was very good and staff was super friendly despite me ordering 30 minutes before closing on a busy weekend. Hope they add aa Alfredo chicken spinach bacon...

paige-dorrell

24.01.2024 - 13:47

Goodfellas is a small pizza place less than 2 miles from a small community I am visiting on Grand Lake. There aren 't many options around here, and I didn 't ha...

amy-addington

24.01.2024 - 13:47

Super yummy pizza with good prices.

brad-smith-dog6

24.01.2024 - 13:47

I ordered the gluten free pizza and hands down it was the best I've had anywhere ! I highly recommend it. The staff was fun and pleasant !!

Last update : 24.01.2024

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Afton

The Artichoke

4.9

Table booking

4.9

Table booking

City: Langley (near Afton), 35878 S Highway 82OK 74350, Langley, United States

"The restaurant is CLOSED! Still taking reservations but it isn't even open for business!"

##1 Pizza in Langley

Details

#1 Pizza in Langley American Steak

Green Country Cafe

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Afton, 21601 US-69, Afton, USA, United States

"Very good home cooked breakfast. T was pretty crowded when we arrived but that didn't affect our wait time to get our breakfast. Everything was perfect. Service: Dine in Meal type: Breakfast Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3"

#Coffee

Details

Coffee Cheese Sandwiches Breakfast Meat

Nowhere On Route 66

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Afton, 300 SE 1st St, Afton, OK, 74331, United States

Terrace, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, TV

#Barbecue

Details

Barbecue Burgers Bars

Pistol Pats

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Disney (near Afton), 320 E Main St, 74340, Disney, US, United States

"What can we say that is negative? Nothing! We visited after a day on the water. The woman who took our order over the phone was the same one who was working the window. She estimated the food to be ready in 30 minutes and it was ready about 10 minutes earlier so luckily we pulled up in time. The food tasted amazing! The ice cream and pop were delicious. The coolest part was visually seeing the Cherokee Syllabary on the side of the building illustration the translation of all the menu items. We had not seen that before in all of Oklahoma. We will be coming back next time we are in town!"

##4 Fast Food in Disney

Details

#4 Fast Food in Disney American

Hi-Way Cafe

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Vinita (near Afton), 437918 E Highway 60 Vinita, OK 74301-7644, United States

"Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Steak"

##3 Fast Food in Vinita

Details

#3 Fast Food in Vinita

Matt's Place

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Grove (near Afton), 2151 US Highway 59, Grove I-74344-3703, United States

"Excellent foodGreat atmosphereService was GREATManagement was very attentive and helpfulOutstanding experience overallWill definitely be back"

##6 Cafés in Grove

Details

#6 Cafés in Grove American Diners

Clanton's Cafe

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: Vinita (near Afton), 319 E Illinois Ave, Vinita I-74301-3235, United States

Terrace, Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Parking

##10 Cafés in Vinita

Details

#10 Cafés in Vinita American Coffee