Stuart's Seafood Market Reviews (84)

Reviews

A restaurant without a rating is almost like a beer garden without a guest. Menulist has collected all reviews for Stuart's Seafood Market so you can get an impression based on the opinions of other visitors. So far, there are 84 evaluations found on 5 pages. The average rating for Stuart's Seafood Market is 4.1, which means guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant. Help other guests with your review through our rating system.

Overall Total Score

4.1 out of 5

Impressive | 84 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Stuart's Seafood Market from all websites.

robin-j-weed9

20.01.2024 - 09:13

As others have said, it?s not the same. Not even close. Every single order I call in is messed up and when I complain, they?re mad at me like I did something wr...

andrea-etienne

20.01.2024 - 09:13

It?s just not the same under new ownership. Three times we?ve bought whole fish, which has smelled absolutely rancid in under 24 hours after squeezing lemon all...

jennifer-podurgiel

20.01.2024 - 09:13

This is a sad review to leave since we?ve loved Stuart?s for years. The new owners have just raised prices to where it?s crazy, steamers are $12 or more a pound...

mark-smith-store1880

20.01.2024 - 09:13

If you're thinking anything seafood Stuarts is place . First and foremost they're good people. The seafood is always fresh, local, and if you want lobsters cook...

Last update : 20.01.2024

This is a sad review to leave since we’ve loved Stuart’s for years. The new owners have just raised prices to where it’s crazy, steamers are $12 or more a pound...

Last update : 17.09.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Amagansett

Almond Bridgehampton

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Bridgehampton (near Amagansett), One Ocean RoadNY 11932, Bridgehampton, United States

"Restaurant management re customer relations is terrific two different people who answered the phone were equally gracious and accommodating as we needed to change our reservation twice. And the reception upon arrival was warm and efficient, immediately seating us at our table. Service was a bit hit or miss; we waited so long for my wife's drink to arrive that over that time she changed her mind, and we had time to change the order to the same thing I was drinking. The tuna poke salad and burrata appetizers were both delicious; my wife felt her burrata was the best she'd tasted. And the roast chicken and peach cake were equally good. Restaurant is extremely loud, but feels pleasantly upbeat, and we and other diners all seemed to be having a good time."

##1 Fast Food in Bridgeham...

Details

#1 Fast Food in Bridgehampton

Wölffer Kitchen Amagansett

4.3

City: Amagansett, 4 Amagansett Square Dr, 11930, United States

"Food was good but overpriced. Main dishes are big portion and drinks are great. Staffs are extremely friendly. Patio tables are much more warmer than regular outdoor seats with heaters."

##8 Vegetarian in Amaganse...

Details

#8 Vegetarian in Amagansett Pizza

Muse At The End

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: MONTAUK (near Amagansett), 41 S Euclid AvenueNY 11954, MONTAUK, United States

"Dinner was very good. The hostess was a bit rude but the waitress made up for it. Scampi and Greek chicken were great. Bread pudding too!"

##2 Pizza in MONTAUK

Details

#2 Pizza in MONTAUK

Il Capuccino

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: SAG HARBOR (near Amagansett), 30 Madison St,NY 11963-4418, United States, SAG HARBOR

"The garlic rolls are addictive, I had 3!! The split pea soup, yum but the codfish special was ok, great piece of fish, not knocking that but it was missing some flavor. Now others may disagree, my taste buds have been ruined with spicy foods so I always need a huge burst of flavor, but still delicious. Plus the hostesses and our server were great! Will definitely come back oh and I don't typically eat meat but did try a bite of the Riley and it was pretty damn good. It's hard to find good red meat in America!"

##5 Seafood in SAG HARBOR

Details

#5 Seafood in SAG HARBOR Pizza

Vine Street Cafe

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: SHELTER ISLAND (near Amagansett), 41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States

"Had a solid experience at the restaurant. Took a bit long than expected but food came out delicious. Our waiter was friendly and attentive but the atmosphere was pretty lackluster to me. Quite pricy but there are little options in the area so it is worth checking out. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Fries, Tuna Tacos"

##2 Fast Food in SHELTER I...

Details

#2 Fast Food in SHELTER ISLAND

Maria's Kitchen

4.7

Table booking

4.7

Table booking

City: SHELTER ISLAND (near Amagansett), 55 N Ferry Rd (at Jaspa Rd), Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States

Terrace, TV, Accepts Credit Cards, Delivery

##1 Mexican in SHELTER ISL...

Details

#1 Mexican in SHELTER ISLAND

Harvest On Fort Pond

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Town of East Hampton (near Amagansett), 11 South Emery Street, Town Of East Hampton, 11954, United States Of America, Town of East Hampton

The restaurant and its rooms are wheelchair accessible and thus reachable with a wheelchair or physical limitations, Depending on the weather, you can also sit outside and eat and drink.

##4 Pizza in Town of East...

Details

#4 Pizza in Town of East Hampton

Hooked

4.6

City: MONTAUK (near Amagansett), 34 S Etna Ave, MONTAUK, United States

"We ordered Mahi and Greens and a Mahi sandwich, also lobster bisque. The fish was cooked for perfection and delicious! Salad and also fresh and tasty. My husband also loved the bisque. Very friendly owner!"

##2 Seafood in MONTAUK

Details

#2 Seafood in MONTAUK American

Bridgehampton Inn

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Bridgehampton (near Amagansett), 2266 Montauk Hwy, 11932, Bridgehampton, US, United States

"Consistently good food and service"

##3 European in Bridgehamp...

Details

#3 European in Bridgehampton

18 Bay

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: SHELTER ISLAND (near Amagansett), 23 North Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States

"Chefs Elizabeth and Adam and front of house manager and sommelier Jimmy continue to elevate 18 Bay to greater heights. My take is always that I could eat the appetizer plate and leave totally satisfied. The creativity and execution of the four elements surpasses what one would experience in an entire meal elsewhere. Jimmy has curated a terrific selection of wines ALL available by the glass Why eat anywhere else in the Hamptons. Bravi!!!"

##1 Fast Food in SHELTER I...

Details

#1 Fast Food in SHELTER ISLAND Pizza