Anna Maria Island Creamery And Bakery Menu

What Alissa S likes about Anna Maria Island Creamery And Bakery:
Wonderfully varied dessert selection with high-quality ingredients. I had the coconut cake, Key Lime Pie, and a variety of chocolates and was not disappointed with any of them. The coconut cake was light and fluffy with a not-overly sweet buttercream, and the Key Lime pie had a nice punch of citrus and a creamy exterior that wasn't broken, as many lesser-made ones can be. The chocolates are from a chocolatier in Tamp... View all feedback.

What Teddi G doesn't like about Anna Maria Island Creamery And Bakery:
Horrible service bratty kid that locked the door as soon as we were out the door even though they don't close for another hour. Store was hot and the selection was terrible. Would not recommend. View all feedback.

abby-k-library12

16.10.2023 - 07:20

We walked in at 8:35 P.M and the girls working immediately told us to leave and that they wouldn't were be us because they where closing. They close at 9 P.M so...

amanda-s-cat114

16.10.2023 - 07:20

Yummy gelato!! And I was happy they were open early. I went for a run and wanted a little treat afterward so that was a plus. The mint chocolate chip is what I...

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.

Two Scoops

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Anna Maria Island, 101 South Bay Boulevard, Anna Maria Island, 34216, United States Of America

"Not once, not twice, but three times this week! Super amazing hand-cuffed ice cream, tasty chilli cream, a fantastic tuna sandwich and much more. The staff was super friendly and the service was on point! We'll be back at our next visit!"

##3 Vegetarian in Anna Mar...

Details

#3 Vegetarian in Anna Maria Island

Pizza Social

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: Anna Maria Island, 308 Pine Avenue, Anna Maria Island, 34216, United States Of America

Here you can find the menu of Pizza Social in Anna Maria Island. At the moment, there are 41 courses and drinks on the food list. You can inquire about seasonal or weekly deals via phone.

##1 Pizza in Anna Maria Is...

Details

#1 Pizza in Anna Maria Island Lunch

Tyler's Homemade Ice Cream

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: Cortez (near Anna Maria Island), 11904 Cortez Rd W, Cortez I-34215, United States

Accepts Credit Cards, Wheelchair Accessible, Terrace, Parking

##3 European in Cortez

Details

#3 European in Cortez

Dips Ice Cream

4.3

City: Anna Maria (near Anna Maria Island), 503 Pine Ave, 34216, Anna Maria, US, United States

"Second year visiting AMI, just had to come back to Dip 's after our experience in 2022. Summer of 2023 was completely different. Service and quality are non existent this summer. When the machines cannot keep up with the amount of orders being taken they continue to serve anyway. Instead of receiving ice cream, you receive a cone upside down in a bowl of milk. Then when you question it or say this is not what you ordered they ask why you have an attitude bro . Manager/Owner was not too helpful either. He was more concerned about his workers reputation rather than making a spectacle of the situation in front of 50+ waiting customers. He also talked bad about another ice cream business very close to his. Small business owners are supposed to lift each other up and not dog each other. He also claims I cursed his worker out, absolutely not true. Luckily for us, he asked us if we wanted our money back and did get it all back to us. 3 of our orders went straight to the trash. The other one was drank. I suggest if you have to try Dip 's for yourself, ensure you ask if the machines are working properly. Otherwise, you will receive a milkshake even if you didn 't order it. It would be zero stars but google is forcing us to put one. The Mayeux Family"

##7 Vegetarian in Anna Mar...

Details

#7 Vegetarian in Anna Maria

Sage Biscuit Cafe

4.5

City: Bradenton (near Anna Maria Island), 6656 Cortez Rd W, 34210-2600, Bradenton, United States

"Our favorite breakfast ever! All we bring here, beg to get out of all places where we take them. Mimosas, eggs Benedict with cookies, sage cookies are all to die for as well as everything you order here!"

##16 Seafood in Bradenton

Details

#16 Seafood in Bradenton

Anna Maria Island Creamery And Bakery