Rod Reel Pier - Anna Maria

What Aimee B likes about Rod Reel Pier:
I was hesitant to try this restaurant after the years of hype, and what seemed like perpetual long waits for a table. But my son and I popped in one chilly evening for dinner and got a table immediately. The menu was not very extensive. I asked the waiter what I should order and he suggested, the grouper sandwich and told me how he prefers it. And I ordered it exactly as he suggested and it was spot on. Delicious! Si... View all feedback.

What Brittany D doesn't like about Rod Reel Pier:
They charge market price plus for frozen seafood. My husband ordered the Grouper Reuben and it was market price $28. The Grouper was not fresh and didn't even cover the bread. We would gladly pay the price for fresh seafood but what a disappointment to go eat over the water to get food from the freezer section of the grocery store. Neat location would be amazing if they served local seafood. Go see the views then go... View all feedback.