Acme Pie Company - Feedback

The most delicious pies I've ever had! Most highly recommended!!! Try something savory and take something sweet home for later.

Updated review: STILL 5/5 Pies: Crust is still amazing as always. Their pies aren't too sweet, so eating a slice doesn't feel like a struggle. Their fruit pies...

Quaint little pie shop is a hidden gem in Arlington, thank goodness we found it using yelp. The staff Anabelle and Lila were friendly and welcoming, had great s...

Came in 30 mins before closing on a Thursday. We were greeted nicely. There was a couple ahead of us ordering a bunch of slices. Older women comes from around t...

The only experience I've had with Acme Pie so far is with their Cookies which I discovered at a library function they were THE BEST!!! I plan to stop by one of...

Absolutely LOVE this place! Best pie I've had outside of my grandma's kitchen! Amazing!

I ordered the sour cherry and pecan chocolate for Thanksgiving and was utterly disappointed. The cherry was filled with an almost gelatin concoction which I tho...

I was in the mood for desert and a place to read the paper (yes I occasionally still read the paper on Sundays. Acme easily fulfilled both needs. It was a quiet...

I am visiting and stumbled upon the best pie I've had in the country. Good ice cream for the pie and a great pie flavor variety. Earned my first yelp review.

Stellar pie shop. I’ve never been let down and have tried most flavors. It’s hard to find a dessert place that specializes in pie.

Had ordered a cake on the phone and when we showed up, they said they had not reserved this cake. the service was generally bad. ab mai also their social distan...

I love the blackberry cake here, and generally fruitcakes have been good (berries better than apple). The vegan quiches were simply ok, but it is still quite co...

I tried the blackberry lime, strawberry rhubarb, apple and spring berries. The crust is killer. My favorite was the blackberry lime, second was apple. Look forw...

I only have three cakes. They're all great. And the piestress was very helpful and accommodating.

Had ordered a cake on the phone and when we showed up, they said they didn't keep that cake. The service was generally bad. From May, their social distancing pr...

I paid $13 for two small slices of pie. While the crust was delicious, the pecan maple chocolate pie was disappointing as it lacked any actual chocolate flavor....

I ordered the sour cherry and pecan chocolate pies for Thanksgiving and I was completely let down. The cherry pie had a strange gelatin filling that I initially...

This pie shop is excellent. I have always been satisfied and have sampled most of their flavors. It's rare to find a dessert spot that focuses on pies.

Very robust and deep pies, not sweet, but very good. As someone who is gluten intolerant and has sensitive teeth, I had no issues with the pecan pie or the blac...

Bought a Classic Apple Pie for a friend's birthday and it was a big hit! If you're a pie fan, you won't be disappointed! Friendly staff a cute atmosphere.

I really enjoy the blackberry pie at this restaurant, and in general, the fruit pies are all delicious (berries are better than apple). The vegan quiches are ju...

I just ordered three pizzas. They were all excellent. The pizza maker was very helpful and accommodating.

I sampled the blackberry lime, strawberry rhubarb, apple, and springberry pies. The crust is outstanding. My top picks were the blackberry lime and apple, in th...

Ordered a pie on the phone and when we showed up they said they didn’t reserve that pie. The service was generally poor. As of May, their social distancing prot...

I absolutely adore the sour cherry pie at this restaurant! The service was top-notch and the atmosphere was polite and clean. It's a great spot to visit once CO...

The apple pie at this restaurant is simply amazing, with a heavenly crust. It's the first apple pie I've ever had that rivals my own mother's recipe!

The root beer float and Scottish apple pie with whiskey-soaked raisins were delicious!