Reviews
As of now, there are 373 ratings available from 8 website(s). The mean score for Paul's Pizza is 4.2, implying that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant.
What User likes about Paul's Pizza:
Most important part of the pizza taste of the sauce. Sauce had the right flavor, nice toppings, right amount of cheese. Coming from NJ it's hard to get pizza in VT that's similar, but this seems to be the closest (crust still a little thicker than used to but tastes good). If you like NY/NJ pies, you'll enjoy this. It's the only pizza place around we've been back to more than once. The new owners have really stepped... View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Paul's Pizza:
VERY DISAPPOINTED!!!! My boyfriend and I ordered the stuffed shells and a calzone and a small tossed salad..Extremely expensive and the portions are pathetic. I felt like I was ripped off. 40 dollars later and I didnt even have leftovers.. The stuffed shells were 8.50 and they only give you 3 of them, which were swimming in marinara sauce that tasted like they had dumped a bucket of sugar in it...I asked for a side o... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Pizza delivery of four pizzas. Everything was very good. W we especially loved the pizza crust. Delivery was on time.
Super nice people who bent over backwards for us, plus ample portions, make for a great experience and it really deserves the family name. Stuff like that sure...
read moreTerrible service waited an hour over the phone to pick up when the guy told me 25-30 minutes.. Will not return and pizza was mediocre
I frequent Paul’s Family Pizza. I love it here. Very friendly service and always consistent with their food. My go-to is a Buffalo Chicken Calzone, but I’ve had...
read moreWhy I hadn’t tried them before I don’t know. Best pizza I’ve had in years.
{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreFood was great new owners service was awesome they had gluten free for my daughter prices were good place was clean most of all crust was awesome
Excellant service and fresh food. The Pizza is really good and the specials are always good..If you like cheesecake they have great cheesecake when available..u...
read moreFirst time since new owners ! super friendly fast courteous hot and ready as expected! Pizza was tasty and definitely worth the Tuesday night special! Can't wai...
read moreThis is the second worst restaurant in Castleton. The first is located right across the parking lot. I'm 100% certain this is owned by the same people. Food is...
read moreI have eaten here a few times and tried almost everything. My favorite is the chicken tenders and salad ! So good !!
{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreExcellent pizza. Fast and friendly service. Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Che...
read moreI haven’t been to Paul’s in years. Didn’t have a great experience there before but had a craving for pizza so we gave them a shot “under new ownership”. You wal...
read moreGreat menu!! So friendly and nice and delivered to lake bomoseen koa! Service: Delivery Meal type: Lunch Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Ch...
read moreOrdered a calzone from here. Very tasty! Great prices and they're generous with toppings as well. Definitely plan on ordering from here again in the future! Ser...
read moreI’d give 10 stars if it let me. The food was delicious and the customer service was top tier. Love this place! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreMy wife and I come here and dine in. Very comfortable friendly atmosphere to eat at. Wish google would get the hours corrected they are open on sundays 4-12
Very friendly place. The employees and owners were very nice and pleasant. As well as great service. The food has always been amazing and freshly made! I highly...
read moreWe were unable to get dinner in town due to a large event and Paul's pizza came through! Great pizza and calzones at an even better price!
Staying at Lake Bomoseen Lodge and had a pizza delivered. Pizza arrived quickly and very hot! Absolutely delicious! Lots of topping and great sauce. Normally do...
read moreGreat crust! Loved the pizza. Definitely will go back.
{{ slotProps.result.title | strip_tags | str_limit(60) }}
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more