Godfathers Pizza Reviews (211)

Menulist has collected all the evaluations for Godfathers Pizza from various portals to give you a transparent impression. Currently, there are 211 evaluations from 8 website(s) available to you. The average rating for Godfathers Pizza is 3.9 which means that the vast majority of its guests was satisfied with its service. Help other guests with your review for this establishment!.

Overall Total Score

3.9 out of 5

Very good | 211 reviews

Reviews from various websites

All reviews for Godfathers Pizza from all websites. The restaurant offers good food (3.9 stars) and is one of the best restaurants in Cayuga Canada.

katherine-hedley

27.12.2023 - 09:19

I ordered a pizza on Tuesday, December 5, 2023 and it was a great pizza! Kudos to the girls working that night because the pizza was absolutely delicious and th...

danny-heffner-3

27.12.2023 - 09:19

Pizza was great. Hot and fresh !!!

heather-s-student9

27.12.2023 - 09:19

Delicious pizza and kind staff.

suzanne-csapo

27.12.2023 - 09:19

Meghan gave exceptional, prompt and friendly service. Each time I pickup pizza from this location she is always friendly! Thanks Meghan!!!

bliss

27.12.2023 - 09:19

Pizza was not the greatest. they are Price gouging at festivals/racetracks. Not a way to support the community. 38$ for a large cold pizza with little to no che...

Last update : 27.12.2023

You need to register or login to leave feedback.

Good Rated Restaurants near Cayuga Canada

D and D's Family Dining

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: JARVIS (near Cayuga Canada), 2091 Main St N, Jarvis, Ontario N0A 1J0, Canada, N0A1J0, JARVIS

"D&D's is a great place to bring your family or just a night out with your spouse. Get food and excellent service."

##2 Seafood in JARVIS

Details

#2 Seafood in JARVIS

Sunflower Cafe

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Selkirk (near Cayuga Canada), 1 Main St W, Selkirk, Ontario N0A 1P0, Canada, N0A1P0

"We drove to Selkirk to walk the Wheeler's Trail in the provincial park. But with all the recent rains, the trail was too muddy. So we walked along Lakeshore to get in our morning steps. Then back to Selkirk for breakfast, we read a review last year about it and always enjoy breakfast out. Good server, good coffee, good home cooked food. My husband always orders his eggs over medium, and the yolks always come out too runny or too hard. Not this time they were just right! Really good bacon too, with a smoky aftertaste. The review also mentioned that they had great carrot cake, so we ordered two pieces to take home. Carrot cake is our favourite dessert, we order it whenever we see it on menus, so feel we can judge the offerings pretty well. I don't know what the reviewer was eating, but this was truly the worst carrot cake we have ever had. The texture was weird, very granular, almost as if made with cornmeal. It wasn't listed as gluten free, which can have a weird mouth feel. Also missing were the lovely combo of spices that you usually find in carrot cake. It was very dry. However, the cream cheese frosting was excellent. SO if we lived closer to Selkirk, this would definitely be on our list of regular breakfast spots. The carrot cake not so much!"

#Canadian

Details

Canadian Diners Breakfast-brunch

Caruso's Family

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Cayuga (near Cayuga Canada), 35 Talbot St. E., Cayuga, ON, Canada N0A 1E0

"Wonderful family restaurant. Wonderful family. Had a delicious lunch with my gang. Great variety of offerings, for adults and kids. Home made pizza with thin crust was excellent. Wraps, burgers, meatball sub, quesadillas, and more. All arrived at the table piping hot. Delicious. Owners are wanting everyone to feel relaxed and enjoy their meal. We will be back. Dave&Carol"

#Family

Details

Family Pizza Tea Fish Sandwich

Dairy Queen Grill Chill

City: Caledonia (near Cayuga Canada), 216 Argyle St S, Caledonia, Canada

"Very clean. The staff was helpful because we were not sure what to order. The food came fast and right. Overall very happy with experience again many times I am sure service: Dine in Meal type: price per person: $10–20 food: 5 service: 5 atmosphere: 5."

##9 Fast Food in Caledonia

Details

#9 Fast Food in Caledonia Ice Cream

Country Chip Wagon

4.6

City: Dunnville (near Cayuga Canada), 8232 Hwy 3 W, Dunnville I-N1A 2W4, Canada

"Love the fish and chips so good and fresh and amazing staff that serve you as well"

#Canadian

Details

Canadian Lunch Ice Cream Sandwiches

Ye Olde Fisherville Restaurant

4.4

Online table booking

4.4

Online table booking

City: Haldimand County (near Cayuga Canada), 3 Erie Ave S, Fisherville, Ontario N0A 1G0, Canada, N0A1G0, Haldimand County

"Yummy food, good fast service and friendly service. That's important! Roomy for large parties. Decor is nice."

#Canadian

Details

Canadian Bars Fish Soup Cheese

Julia's Bistro

4.1

Online table booking

4.1

Online table booking

City: Dunnville (near Cayuga Canada), 217 Niagara St | At Broad St, Dunnville, Ontario N1A 2A9, Canada, N1A2A9

"If you order a sandwich and they ask if you want fries. Here what happen they charge for a very small handful of fries that are the bottom of the bag."

##7 Cafés in Dunnville

Details

#7 Cafés in Dunnville Italian Pizza

Twisted Lemon

4.2

Online table booking

4.2

Online table booking

City: Cayuga (near Cayuga Canada), 3 Norton Street WestON N0A1E0, N0A 1E0, Cayuga, Canada

"Comparable to some of the best restaurants in Toronto tucked away in the country!"

#French

Details

French Ice Cream Fish Soup Meat

Pizza Hut Caledonia

4.3

Online table booking

4.3

Online table booking

City: Caledonia (near Cayuga Canada), 172 Argyle St N, Caledonia, Canada

On this webpage, you can find the complete menu of Pizza Hut Caledonia from Caledonia. Currently, there are 1 dishes and drinks available. For seasonal or weekly deals, please contact the owner of the restaurant directly. You can also contact them through their website.

##4 Pizza in Caledonia

Details

#4 Pizza in Caledonia Delivery