Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackThe average rating for Goodfellas Pizzeria Baxter Ave. is 4.1, which means that the customers have a very high opinion of this place.
What Doug Cooper likes about Goodfellas Pizzeria Baxter Ave.:
Amazing craft cocktails, really good pizza, and great service! The bartenders were awesome, and the place is clean as a whistle! Even if you don't like pizza, it's worth it to go for the drinks. View all feedback.
What Josiah Davis doesn't like about Goodfellas Pizzeria Baxter Ave.:
If you're looking for a place that tells you your single pizza will take 35 minutes, then has you wait for another 30 minutes after you get there, all for a pretty okay pizza, look no further. Pizza was decent. Getting it was not. View all feedback.
This place is AMAZING!!! The customer service and the pizza is a 10/10! The speak easy in the back was such a nice surprise and the drinks were phenomenal! Def...
read moreI was somewhat disappointed in the pizza, here. After all the talk, I just expected more. The staff seemed very nice and all, but there are too many other pizza...
read moreFull Menu
Download MenuHere you'll find in addition to selected meals, a comprehensive drinks selection, and various dish categories. The menu card is regularly expanded by customer recommendations and ingredients recommended by guests in a commendable way. The menu card may be enriched on site by daily or weekly special offers.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
