Pookaberry Cafe - Mattituck

Based on the average rating of 4.3, the Pookaberry Cafe is definitely worth a visit.

What Andrea Urist likes about Pookaberry Cafe:
The restaurant wasn’t fully set up yet but the owners were so accommodating and friendly. They set up a table for me and my mom. We ordered the Bang Bang shrimp to share, which was delicious and flavorful. My mom wanted a pasta dish and the chef suggested a cilantro pasta with grilled chicken. It was like a cilantro pesto.. delicious! The chicken could have been a bit spicier. I ordered beef over yellow rice. The bee... View all feedback.

What Carol Sullivan doesn't like about Pookaberry Cafe:
Was thrilled to have a new place in town until I went there. Ordered fish chips to split with a friend as was charge for 2 plus an extra order of fries. It was definitely one portion and a meager one at that. Asked for tartar sauce, didn't have it; asked for vinegar and got balsamic. Perhaps they need to do some research on a classic English dish. Waiter made the bill right, but with lots of attitude.Dining is room i... View all feedback.