Brewster's Italian Café - New Buffalo

The average review for Brewster's Italian Café is 4.3, which means that the customers have a very high opinion of this place.

What Shauna Roberts likes about Brewster's Italian Café:
Stopped here on our way home from Northern Michigan. There was a short wait for a table on a bust Saturday night. My husband ordered a spicy pizza, and I had shrimp Alfredo. We also had the ricotta and honeycomb on crostini and the brownie carmel tiramisu for dessert. Everything was good. The dessert was enough for 3. The waitress was friendly and helpful. I also have to hand it to the hostess on keeping calm and res... View all feedback.