Brewster's Italian Café Reviews (2938)

Reviews

Currently you have 2938 rating from 3 website(s) available. The average rating for Brewster's Italian Café is 4.3 which means that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant.

Overall Total Score

4.3 out of 5

Impressive | 2938 reviews

Reviews from various websites

22.11.2023 - 14:20

I've lived in New Buffalo for over 30 year's anyone coming to NB must try Brewster's.

jonathon-rearick

22.11.2023 - 14:20

It is a great place. Food was excellent. Make sure to make reservations. It is very busy and popular.

shelley-guidarelli

22.11.2023 - 14:20

They add a convenience fee for using cash vs. credit card... The food is ok but lunch was overpriced.

22.11.2023 - 14:20

We had the BEST dinner experience at Brewster's last night. The food was exceptional as always, but the service stood out on so many levels. I made a reservatio...

22.11.2023 - 14:20

Stopped here on our way home from Northern Michigan. There was a short wait for a table on a bust Saturday night. My husband ordered a spicy pizza, and I had sh...

Last update : 22.11.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near New Buffalo

Oink's Dutch Treat

4.7

Menu

Table booking

4.7

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 227 W Buffalo StMI 49117, New Buffalo, United States

"Some of the best ice cream on the planet."

##26 Cafés in New Buffalo

#26 Cafés in New Buffalo American

Song Asian Cuisine

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 301 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, USA, United States

Delivery, Wheelchair Accessible, Parking area, Takeout

##13 Seafood in New Buffal...

#13 Seafood in New Buffalo Chinese

Copper Rock Steakhouse Four Winds Casino Resort

4.7

Menu

Table booking

4.7

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 11111 Wilson RoadMI 49117, New Buffalo, United States

"The meal and service was outstanding. Can't wait to go again."

##2 Seafood in New Buffalo

#2 Seafood in New Buffalo

Terrace Room

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 111 W Water St, New Buffalo, USA, United States

"Will be back...thoroughly recommend"

##5 Seafood in New Buffalo

#5 Seafood in New Buffalo

Bentwood Tavern

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 600 W Water St, New Buffalo, USA, 49117, United States

"Great space , service and fun food!"

##8 Pizza in New Buffalo

#8 Pizza in New Buffalo

Rios Mexican Grill #1

4.4

Menu

Table booking

4.4

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 901 W Buffalo St, New Buffalo, USA, United States

"Worth the wait. Order ahead online."

##9 Fast Food in New Buffa...

#9 Fast Food in New Buffalo

Skip's And Catering

4.5

Menu

Table booking

4.5

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 16710 Lakeshore Rd, New Buffalo, USA, 49117, United States

"Big eat only a little pricy, but what is now days?"

##17 Seafood in New Buffal...

#17 Seafood in New Buffalo Cafés

The Stray Dog And Grill

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: New Buffalo, 245 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, Michigan, USA, 49117, United States

"Wonderful cheeseburger. Love the fish tacos too. Great service."

##8 Fast Food in New Buffa...

#8 Fast Food in New Buffalo

3rd Base Grill

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: La Porte (near New Buffalo), 1201 Pine Lake Rd, La Porte, IN, 46350, United States

"Prime rib dinner special Wow! So tasty corn mashed potatos creamy horse radish salad to start! Enjoyed every bite and leftovers. Saw a lot of..."

##39 Fast Food in La Porte

#39 Fast Food in La Porte American

Zorn Brew Works

4.3

Menu

Table booking

4.3

Menu

Table booking

City: Michigan City (near New Buffalo), 605 E Ninth St, Michigan City, Indiana, USA, 46360, 46360-3651, United States

"Very good beer and good food even with the limited menu."

American Western Brewery Bar-Lounge