Carmella's Cafe - NEW HARTFORD

In the category Seafood, this restaurant is listed among the best in NEW HARTFORD, and based on the average review of 4.4, Carmella's Cafe has so far greatly satisfied its visitors.

What NancyP likes about Carmella's Cafe:
I couldn't have had a better experience at Caremella's Cafe this trip! We made a reservation for 8 about 45 min ahead of time (surprised this was eve possible). We even got there about 15 min early and they were able to seat us immediately (we were coming from an event and the travel time was unpredictable). The service was outstanding, the food was great, and the prices were awesome (esp the free dinner for children... View all feedback.

What BarbaraN doesn't like about Carmella's Cafe:
We were well received. Manager and server were super friendly. Our server, however, forgot to put in one of our meals. The rest of us were done eating before her meal came out if the kitchen. Our server apologized, but no restitution was made which was too bad. Food was a bit pricey for the quality. View all feedback.