Reviews
What Cherri Glidden likes about Old Island Pub:
My absolute favorite place to eat off season. You MUST get the pub fries with the proprietary dipping sauce! My go- to is always the broccoli Reuben (vegetarian). It NEVER disappoints. The staff is so very friendly as well. View all feedback. What Josh Thompson doesn't like about Old Island Pub:
There’s a reason this place was empty on a Saturday in August. The food was dry and over cooked, the drinks were diluted and the bartender was completely disrespectful. (Older lady). There are sooo many better bars on the island that actually appreciate your business! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Awesome small tavern with an older vibe. Nice vs. the alternatives.
There’s a reason this place was empty on a Saturday in August. The food was dry and over cooked, the drinks were diluted and the bartender was completely disres...
read moreMy absolute favorite place to eat off season. You MUST get the pub fries with the proprietary dipping sauce! My go- to is always the broccoli Reuben (vegetarian...
read moreGreat pizza and pub fries, great bartender (tom), great people on a calm Easter Sunday. Can't go wrong with this pub.
Friendly service. We had a private function and I felt so welcomed by all there. The food prepared was top notch! Food cooked so uniquely and served to perfecti...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreWas there yesterday during the BI Stroll. Only 2 bars open, so they were busy. Seated at the bar we enjoyed 2 drinks each from Alicja, the bartender. I then mad...
read moreI hit this place up on Taco Tuesday and wasn't disappointed. Great food and beer.
Beautiful pub. Great people. Blue collar type spot. Nothing fancy, which is what I wanted!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more