Reviews
What Jayne D doesn't like about Casey Key Fish House.:
Good at Casey Key Fish House is very disappointing. Vegetables aren't fresh and presentation is lacking. The chairs are plastic lawn chairs and the ambiance is lacking inside. The outside Tiki Bar is a fun place to have a drink. The view is the only thing that makes this a tourist destination. View all feedback. What Carol B likes about Casey Key Fish House.:
First time to eat at this amazing restaurant . We sat out on the dock and enjoyed our dinner of snapper, crab cakes, and shrimp. Server did a great job. Will definitely return. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
We always wanted us to find room here. This time we were successful. Service was very good. Eat fresh seafood, excellent. What a look!. We sat near the water vi...
read moreBest beer broken shrimp ever! I had to go over the house salad with hot sauce and blue cheese, so good! First time and we'll be back! Loved the atmosphere and f...
read moreFantastic meal! I had the sea red tuna and only really the accompanying aromas of ginger and wasabi. The part was also very generous. And I don't know if we eve...
read morethis place lies on the water with a beautiful view. they can rent kajaks and boats from this location. there is a great tiki bar to hang around and drink drinks...
read moreMy brother and I got take out for lunch, which was delicious! (The calamari was fantastic!! Highly recommended) Such a cozy, tropical atmosphere here! It's righ...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read moreCasey Key Fish House offers a mixed dining experience, with some customers left disappointed by the lackluster food and service. Complaints varied from poorly prepared appetizers to tasteless fish, but the open-air seating and waterfront view proved to be highlights for many. The Tiki Bar was praised as a fun place to enjoy a drink, with friendly and engaging staff adding to the overall positive atmosphere. Some diners were impressed by the delicious food, particularly the mussels marinara and grouper sandwich, while others found the dishes to be lacking in flavor and presentation. Despite some mixed reviews, the restaurant's unique location and ambiance seem to make it worth a visit for those looking for a casual dining experience by the water.
Loved the atmosphere here and our server Nicole was awesome. Food was very average, I had ordered the swordfish special and it was almost rubbery like it had be...
read moreGreat casual dining right on the water. Staff was very friendly and engaging. Went for a late lunch. recommend the mussels marinara and the grouper sandwich. Bo...
read moreAuthentic local cuisine and good drinks at value driven prices. We really recommend this place to anyone passing through or staying for vacation.
Horrible service, fish has no taste, fries like sponge. Mostly mad about them packaging 1 piece of mahi for to go although they say it should be 2. Fish dip is...
read moreGreat place to go, there's the fish house then the open air tiki Hut. Our Server Nicole was amazing, she was there if we needed anything, didn't hover, brought...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more