Plymouth Pizzeria Reviews (138)

Reviews

To date you have access to 138 reviews from 3 website(s). The median rating for Plymouth Pizzeria is 4.4, signifying that guests have a very high opinion of this restaurant.

Overall Total Score

4.4 out of 5

Impressive | 138 reviews

Reviews from various websites

That was our first time that Plymouth Pizzeria tried. It was excellent!! Pizza was so good and the bites were very good. Lotsa Sauce!!! I'm back.

At 8:00, they didn't know they closed at 9:00. My wing stitches were hot, loved the mild sauce. My personal pan pizza came hot and fresh, reminded me of a sweet...

I gave no rating of a star, I gave a five star rating! We enjoyed the pizza, onion rings and garlic knots. The restaurant was very clean and tidy. The remaining...

I own the Lighthouse Inn of West Wyoming for 30 years. I wish I knew how good Donny's pizza would be because he would run my team for 30 years. Hands down Plymo...

They had great food! Very Tasty! Sodas were a little pricey though!!

Last update : 04.05.2023

Contribute Feedback

Good Rated Restaurants near Plymouth

Gessert's Ice Cream And Confectionery

4.8

Table booking

4.8

Table booking

City: Elkhart Lake (near Plymouth), 99A Lake St, Elkhart Lake I-53020-2104, United States

"24 flavors and lots of toppings and cones. Fun atmosphere!"

##5 Cafés in Elkhart Lake

Details

#5 Cafés in Elkhart Lake American

Deo's Pizzeria And Pub

4.6

City: Plymouth, 417 E Mill St, 53073, Plymouth, United States

"Was in for a sandwich and a drink, was a terrible experience , the waitress was more worried about her computer work and sat at the bar studying on it..."

#American

Details

American North American

Luige's Italian Restaurant

4.3

Table booking

4.3

Table booking

City: Sheboygan (near Plymouth), 2910 Kohler Memorial Drive Sheboygan, WI 53081, United States

"Nice place! Friendly staff! Great food, healthy portions!"

##9 Vegetarian in Sheboyga...

Details

#9 Vegetarian in Sheboygan European

Paddock Club

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: Elkhart Lake (near Plymouth), 61 South Lake Street, Elkhart Lake, 53020, United States Of America

"Excellent steak and seafood with great service. Very recommended."

##4 Seafood in Elkhart Lak...

Details

#4 Seafood in Elkhart Lake

The Duke Of Devon

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Sheboygan (near Plymouth), 793 Riverfront Dr., Sheboygan, United States Of America, 53081

"Last visit before closing this weekend"

##20 Vegetarian in Sheboyg...

Details

#20 Vegetarian in Sheboygan British

The Greek Corner

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: Sheboygan (near Plymouth), 1402 S 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081, United States, 53081-5327

"Good food service a little slow,but worth the wait."

##7 Cafés in Sheboygan

Details

#7 Cafés in Sheboygan Greek Cheese

Paradigm Coffee Music

4.5

Table booking

4.5

Table booking

City: Sheboygan (near Plymouth), 1202 N 8th St, Sheboygan, Wisconsin, USA, 53081, United States

"Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

##5 Fast Food in Sheboygan

Details

#5 Fast Food in Sheboygan

Siebkens Resort

4.4

Table booking

4.4

Table booking

City: Elkhart Lake (near Plymouth), 284 S Lake St, 53020, Elkhart Lake, US, United States

"Nice place. Very busy Service: 4"

##5 Cafés in Elkhart Lake

Details

#5 Cafés in Elkhart Lake Ice Cream

Bread Bean Eatery

4.6

Table booking

4.6

Table booking

City: Sheboygan (near Plymouth), 107 Pine St, Sheboygan Falls, WI 53085, United States

"Good food, good people Meal type: Brunch Price per person: $10–20"

##18 Vegetarian in Sheboyg...

Details

#18 Vegetarian in Sheboygan Seafood

Trattoria Stefano

4.7

Table booking

4.7

Table booking

City: Sheboygan (near Plymouth), 522 S 8th StWI 53081, Sheboygan, United States

"Amazing. this restaurant is a real Italian restaurant! all food tasted much better than my expectations. tiramisu there are 28 years also recipe. the..."

##25 Vegetarian in Sheboyg...

Details

#25 Vegetarian in Sheboygan Italian