Reviews
What User likes about Kinchley's Tavern:
My son and I stayed there for the first time yesterday. We knew the food had to be good because the place was buried for lunch on Saturday. My son ordered a sausage meat sandwich and we split a garlic cake. He turned around the sandwich, but when we tried the pizza, we both said it was when we had the best. I'm originally from the Bronx, so I know a great pizza when I taste one! We don't live nearby, but you can bet... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The best pizza on earth! We're going 10 hours for Kinchleys! Since I was 12 and lived in West Milford. Now we drive from Smith Mountain Lake.
My son and I stayed there for the first time yesterday. We knew the food had to be good because the place was buried for lunch on Saturday. My son ordered a sau...
read moreClean local friendly pizza joint with ingenious cakes...a must have experience... Cash only and always busy.
Great pizza! Love the thin crispy crust! The place is always packed...testament to the good food and atmosphere.
Have been patronizing Kinchley's for the past 50 years. They have the best thin crust pizza ever.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) }}
read more