No images to show

Reserve now

What JimG likes about 18 Bay:
We had heard and read good things about 18 Bay's cuisine, so it had to meet a high bar. It did, cleared the bar with ease. Happy to see Jimmy (formerly of Sweet Tomato) behind the bar and recommending wines, all reasonably priced. Our cocktails off their menu were exceptionally good and it went on from there. Portions (4-course fixed menu, choose only from two entrees) were just right. I really have no criticisms to... View all feedback.

What Natasha doesn't like about 18 Bay:
The food was excellent. The wine pairings very good. My only complaints would be the noise level and a feeling of being rushed, even though we were there for almost two hours. I think it goes with the territory of the limited choice menu, no surprises and everything is set to go in the kitchen. If it had been cooler and drier and we had eaten on the quieter and more intimate porch, I think these « comments » would be... View all feedback.

Menulist
4.0 ★ from 2 reviews
Jaron
18.01.2023 - 15:18

the place is surely unique and the history of the building brings much to the table. service was friendly and accommodating. love the fact that the menu changes...

read more
Leonie
18.01.2023 - 15:18

what a pleasure to visit 18 bay. the entire experience was first guess. the staff is friendly, knowledgeable and efficient, the wine list is expansiw and the ea...

read more
Opentable
4.5 ★ from 386 reviews
Rufus
15.09.2023 - 15:25

Place is certainly unique and the history of the building brings a lot to the table. Service was friendly and accommodating. Love the fact that the menu changes...

read more
Leonie
15.09.2023 - 15:25

What a pleasure to visit 18 Bay. The entire experience was first rate. The staff is friendly, knowledgeable and efficient, the wine list is expansive and the fo...

read more

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Bridgehampton (near SHELTER ISLAND), One Ocean RoadNY 11932, Bridgehampton, United States
"We had the burger special which was great! Terrific service."
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND, 41 South Ferry Road Shelter Island, NY 11964, 11964-9700, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"Jessica was one of the best waitresses we ever had."
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND, 41 S Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"Lovely to be back. Still delicious. Still cozy. Feels like family"
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND, 55 N Ferry Rd (at Jaspa Rd), Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"Delicious fresh authentic Mexican food."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND, 23 North Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"Very good food and pleasant service."
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: East Hampton North (near SHELTER ISLAND), 94 Main St., 11937, East Hampton North, United States
"Perfection, always. A classic in East Hamptons for meat eaters"